Search results for - street racing syndicate full pc game
Total found 203 results





Ethereum bet online software, ethereum bet online volleyball posted an update 1 month, 2 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Ethereum bet online software, ethereum bet online …
Ethereum bet online software, ethereum bet online volleyball posted an update 1 month, 2 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Ethereum bet online software, ethereum bet online Volleyball
Ethereum bet online software Second, there are multiple sports available for live-stream on the mobile app, rather than just horse
Bovada Cricket – 374.4eth
Nitrogen Sports Darts – 664.8ltc
FortuneJack Dota 2 – 320.9ltc
FortuneJack Rugby – 150.1eth
Nitrogen Sports Handball – 668usdt
FortuneJack Floorball – 583.2usdt
365bet Dota 2 – 65.6usdt
Thunderpick NBA – 628.7btc
OneHash Rugby – 61.6ltc
Ethereum bet online software, ethereum bet online volleyball This sportsbook also has stamps of approval from IBIA and IBAS – unbiased bodies ensuring fair odds. So Bet365 sports betting online can be an enjoyable experience for everyone, ethereum bet online software. Bet365 has made eGaming’s power 50 list three times already. And in 2019, SBC awarded Bet365 sports betting “Sportsbook of the Year” for the sixth consecutive year. Yes, in addition to bitcoin, betonline now allows you to deposit/withdraw with litecoin, ethereum, dash and bitcoincash. I don't think monero is supported yet though. In addition to supporting a variety of cryptocurrencies and having the best online poker software for u. Players, betonline is also great because. Betonline is powered by betsoft, one of the most popular online gambling software companies operating today. This software is particularly popular among those who enjoy playing colorful, fun slot machines, as betsoft is the undisputed king of 3d slots, providing many of the most famous titles in this genre. Betonline was one of the first online casinos to start accepting cryptocurrencies and even today they accept more forms of digital currencies than most of their competitors, including bitcoin, litecoin, bitcoin cash, ripple, dash, and ethereum. Betonline is ranked the #3 largest poker site in the usa in terms of traffic, offering a healthy player base. Betonline poker client: overview of the software. Betonline offers a smooth poker client that runs on all popular operating systems, including windows, mac, ios, android, and instant play. Ethereum is a crypto currency launched in june of 2015 which allows users to send and receive payments through the internet without central authorities, taxes or regulations, much like bitcoin. An ethereum stake is when you deposit eth (acting as a validator) on ethereum 2. 0 by sending it to a deposit contract, basically acting as a miner and thus securing the network. At the time of writing in mid-december 2020, the ethereum stake price, or the amount of money earned daily by ethereum validators, is about 0. 00403 eth a day, or $2. Betonline poker is easily the flagship brand of betonline. Ag, but the same software is used by sister site sportsbetting poker as well. The new software client is now one of the better choices in the us poker market, offering better functionality and paving the way for future mobile options. Luckily, you can learn how to use ethereum in a matter of minutes. And once you learn the process, you'll be making ethereum casino deposits in seconds. Here are the steps towards using this cryptocurrency at online casinos: step 1: use fiat (e. Usd) to buy ethereum from an exchange (e. After all, betonline’s new browser-based mobile poker interface gives access to a wide array of software users: android, ios, windows phone, or blackberry players access to texas holdem, omaha, and omaha hi/lo events and more on the way. Pros of the betonline poker room. Is it legal to bet on bitcoin and cryptocurrency performance? betting lines for cryptocurrency index markets are not offered by las vegas, and all domestic sportsbooks in the usa have followed sin city’s example – which is a pretty big sin, in our opinion. The betonline casino uses the rival casino software which is one of the best online casino software packages available. The software is very secure, offers great graphics and is fast. The betonline casino is 100% flash so there is not even any software to download. When it comes to extensive sports betting along with top notch casino
Blockchain-technology-based betting exchange bookie is offering bitcoin prizes in the public beta it will be operating in the run-up to and during this year’s soccer world cup. With the 2018 football world cup in russia a little over 2-months away, the controversial event has gained the attention of decentralized sports betting exchange, bookie. Bitcoin about bitcoin sports betting with bitcoin security tips for bitcoin betting advantages and disadvantages of bitcoin our conclusion about bitcoin considered by some as a controversial form of currency, bitcoin is a digital method of payment created in 2009 by satoshi nakamoto, though that name is likely to be an alias. Bitcoin sportsbook with a lot to offer. From football, basketball, baseball and even the growing esports industry, we have you covered. Io features more than 20 sports, and we endeavour to give you a fair chance of having a betting win by offering competitive odds for each sport. Nfl football betting is available at all bookmakers and various other online gambling sites, but there’s no point just picking one at random! spend a little time considering the advantages of each site we review – one might offer a bigger bonus than another, while another might pay out winnings a little bit quicker. Unlike other crypto betting platforms out there, decibet is built by a team of die-hard football fans who also happen to be some of the best coders. With football as the central theme, decibet is focused purely on crypto betting, supporting a range of virtual currencies including some of the leading privacy coins viz. , dash, zcash and monero. Football betting with bitcoin it may shock you to know that i have a bit of a life outside of maintaining the footy tipster, one of the things i am interested in is cryptocurrencies (bitcoin, etc. Over the last while i’ve noticed more and more services being created that let you use bitcoin to place bets. #1 bitcoin sportsbook for american football betting the cloudbet sportsbook offers unbeatable value at unbeatable odds and unrivalled betting limits of up to 36 btc. Enjoy pre-
Probably you should change config file /app/config, betting football bitcoin calculator. The proxyListAddr address should be return like this because we need host, port, type, username and password for using the proxy. You can leave the address blank. You will need £100 in your Bet365 and £150 in your Betfair Exchange account to complete this offer, ethereum bet sport ice hockey payout. Bet365 Risk Free In Play Offer Summary. Simply use the touch screen to select your
Deposit methods – BTC, USDT, ETH, LTC, XRP, TRX, SOC, EUR, USD, CAD, INR, BRL, Visa, MasterCard, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Bank transfer. blabla

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Live poker bet bitcoin, asia to bet bitcoin posted an update 1 month, 2 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Live poker bet bitcoin, Asia to bet bitcoin
…
Live poker bet bitcoin, asia to bet bitcoin posted an update 1 month, 2 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Live poker bet bitcoin, Asia to bet bitcoin
Live poker bet bitcoin Once you get into the swing of things, you’ll understand why many punters prefer placing bets this way. Are Betting Exchanges available in other countries, live poker bet bitcoin. The simple answer is yes – you can now access betting exchanges in Germany , India, and many more countries. But be sure to check the team and conditions when searching for your desired country. Which betting exchange is the best? At the end of the day, our bookmaker reviews are designed to help you decide which is the best online betting site for you, live poker bet bitcoin. Asia to bet bitcoin Cloudbet is the most secure bitcoin betting site online, offering bitcoin casino gambling or bitcoin sports betting for players around the world. Customer support our customer support team is available 24/7 to help with any questions you might have about betting with cloudbet. Bitcoin casino – bet in btc, bch, eth, usdt, and more cryptos. 5 btc welcome bonus, instant withdrawals, 1000+
Bitcoin smashed through $20,000 for the first time on wednesday, jumping 4. When bitcoin first came into the public eye, it did not take long for people to think about how it could best be used. We saw the huge potential in bitcoin, and we decided to make our service even better for players. By offering bitcoin casino
They also have a Betting Control and Licensing Board (BCLB) license that allows them to operate in the Republic of Tanzania and other African countries. You can contact the support team at 1xbet via email, live chat or telephone, 24 hours 7 days. Betway is an internationally recognized betting site which accepts Tanzanians to deposit and bet on different sports markets in the world, bet bitcoin it go download. The website was launched in 2006 and had an admirable reputation of offering daily events and live betting. Looking at the odds for the Electoral College, there are different states that have been bet on way more than others on BetOnline that if Trump were to win those states, BetOnline could potentially take a huge hit, cricket betting – how bet bitcoin on cricket online. The one thing that all of these states have in common is that they are all typically Democratic states and are favored that way, but bettors have been taking more risks than usual here and betting that they will turn Red. There are going to be quite a number of free bets that you can make use of and claim at several of our featured and top rated betting sites. To help you make sense of them all and to answer any additional questions we have put together the following guide that we invite you to read through, ethereum rugby online betting. Watch The Misery Index, tips sport bet bitcoin. The Misery Index measures economic misery and combines the sum of the percentage inflation rate + the percentage unemployment rate. While Proline in New Brunswick does offer an option to play from home, the online sportsbooks are just so much more user-friendly on mobile or computer. Not only that, but there are additional perks like online casinos or online poker that you can access that would not be available through the lottery, tips sport bet bitcoin. With sports betting becoming more and more mainstream it seems like every week a new state is passing legislation to legalize betting within state lines. This is going to be a rapidly evolving space which is why we are making sure you have all the information you need regardless of where you live, tiger woods vegas bet bitcoin. Online sportsbooks in the UK treat residents to all sorts of creative lines, covering everything from the London mayoral election, to the next leaders of each major party, to the next general election, free soccer bitcoin prediction correct score. Bookies include options to bet on either the next winning party or next Prime Minister in the generals. The Betsson brand is enjoyed by thousands of fans on a daily basis be it on their casino or in this case the Betsson sports betting site. Betsson is well known for providing top class facilities to its members and the sports book is no different, bet sport ethereum nba no kyc. It should be remembered that Betfair is the official betting partner of Real Madrid CF, CONMEBOL Sudamericana and CONMEBOL Libertadores, draw no bet bitcoin in bet9ja meaning. All customers have assured maximum security as the betting site is protected using impenetrable security systems like 256-bit Secure Socket Layer (SSL) encryption. Bettors will also benefit from free handicapping tips and useful information if you are new to horse
BetFlip Tennis – 582.7dog
FortuneJack Table Tennis – 100.7dog
Betflip Snooker – 443.1btc
1xBit American Football – 141.2usdt
BetFlip NBA – 316.1dog
BetOnline Handball – 605.7eth
1xBit Soccer – 7.4ltc
Thunderpick Darts – 440.5dog
1xBit Handball – 701.1eth
Sports events: Deposit methods 2021 – BTC, USDT, ETH, LTC, XRP, TRX, SOC, EUR, USD, CAD, INR, BRL, Visa, MasterCard, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Bank transfer. blabla

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Bitcoin sportsbook
CLICK HERE >>> Bitcoin sportsbook
Bitcoin sportsbook
CLICK HERE >>> Bitcoin sportsbook
Bitcoin sportsbook
Thunderpick Basketball – 154usdt
1xBit Snooker – 150.2btc
Betflip CS:GO – 211bch
365bet Soccer – 406.1usdt
365bet Handball – 730.7usdt
Nitrogen Sports NBA – 483.1dog
OneHash Dota 2 – 368.4bch
BetFlip CS:GO – 103.6bch
BetFlip Soccer – 537.9usdt
Bitcoin sports betting, RugbyBet bitcoin 888 slots, bitcoin sportsbook eamerican football Bitcoin sportsbook
Slots are usually the largest contributor to meeting wagering requirements of an ndb, usually at 100% while a
Green launched its sportsbook, which has seen a similar rise up the ranks. With over 35 sports to choose from, as well as some non sport betting options, Mr. Green is already found in the top 10 on most user review sites, bet bitcoin 888 slots. They’ve also created an exciting Mr Green free bet. Offers such as the Mr. Bet365 Tennis Bonus Serves up an Ace for Punters, bitcoin sportsbook handball withdrawal. The Bet365 Tennis Bonus on Acca’s promotion. You can suffer symptoms of stress, anxiety or hyperactivity migraines once you start to invest too much of your time into it, bitcoin sportsbook darts. Some people tend to worry too much when they start losing real money. So, if you play the U, bitcoin sportsbook table tennis. Mega Millions 5/70

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Cryptocurrency bet online Boxingbook, cryptocurrency bet sport rocket league payout posted an update 1 month, 2 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Cryptocurrency bet online …
Cryptocurrency bet online Boxingbook, cryptocurrency bet sport rocket league payout posted an update 1 month, 2 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Cryptocurrency bet online Boxingbook, cryptocurrency bet sport Rocket League payout
Cryptocurrency bet online Boxingbook The funds will be debited from your account within seventy-two hours from the moment of sending your withdrawal request. Betsofa can charge the withdrawal fees. Skip to the casino’s site to know what withdrawal fees will be charged from you, cryptocurrency bet online boxingbook. I would like to say., cryptocurrency bet online boxingbook. Cryptocurrency bet sport Rocket League payout Players from the united states may join most cryptocurrency online casinos and betting sites only when depositing in cryptocurrency. Be sure to know the online
Betcoin.ag Boxing – 281.9dog
OneHash American Football – 387.3eth
Betcoin.ag Ice Hockey – 469eth
Bovada Soccer – 747.5eth
365bet UFC – 659.5btc
Nitrogen Sports Ice Hockey – 22.5usdt
Betflip Snooker – 10.5dog
1xBit Snooker – 690.3eth
365bet Cricket – 67.6dog
Best crypto Rugby bookmaker live bet, cryptocurrency bet online script Cryptocurrency bet online Boxingbook, Live bitcoin bets, NBA. You might also like: Broken Sword series, The Moment of Silence, cryptocurrency bet online boxingbook. Perhaps the
The crypto sports betting industry has advanced a lot of the past couple of years to the point where sites like cloudbet now live stream nba basketball and spanish soccer for free. Io now allow their players to close bets by opting for
Initially marred by some technical issues upon its release in 1998, including a

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Crypto eVolleyball live betting site, crypto evolleyball betting site posted an update 1 month, 3 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Crypto eVolleyball live betting site, crypto …
Crypto eVolleyball live betting site, crypto evolleyball betting site posted an update 1 month, 3 weeks ago
CLICK HERE >>> Crypto eVolleyball live betting site, crypto eVolleyball betting site
Crypto eVolleyball live betting site Also, you need a lot of money in the exchange if you start going for higher odds matches. If you consistently choose matches in the lower range of 5-8, crypto evolleyball live betting site. Also, you need a lot of money in the exchange if you start going for higher odds matches at £50 stakes. What is a Half-Time
365bet Soccer – 362.2usdt
365bet Ice Hockey – 364.4eth
365bet Dota 2 – 409.4usdt
OneHash Darts – 442.2ltc
OneHash Volleyball – 523.1usdt
Thunderpick UFC – 399.8bch
Bovada Rocket League – 173.3btc
FortuneJack CS:GO – 317.7bch
Betflip Dota 2 – 265.4ltc
Nba bitcoin odds today vegas, crypto evolleyball bookmaker live bet Crypto eVolleyball live betting site, Bet bitcoin sport, Floorball. Normally, the man of the match is awarded to a player from the winning team and that too to a batsman unless a bowler does exceptionally well. This is another type of betting market that bettors like to punt on and here you need to predict which team’s opening batsmen will score more number of runs between them in a match, crypto evolleyball live betting site. This involves a great deal of research as a certain opening batsman may have a poor record against a certain bowler of the opposition. This quickly turned as 11 players on the Titans tested positive for COVID-19, crypto evolleyball live betting site. Crypto eVolleyball live betting site, Bitcoin sportsbook, Cricket. Wagering requirements must be met within 30 days for bonus money to become real money, crypto evolleyball betting site.
Tuesday 1/26/2021 nba and college basketball picks from the legend! $20 special today on make your wallet fat again, tuesday! get guaranteed winners on three best bets – college basketball vegas wiseguy information lock, college basketball vegas high roller play and college basketball sharp bettors edge play today from the legend. The live vegas odds page for nba focuses on presenting each sportsbook’s odds for each day’s
For Coates, the best paid female executive in the world, it was not even a one-off. A year earlier, she handed herself £217m from the profits of what remains a private family owned business, albeit one worth billions. All the numbers associated with Bet365 are big: gamblers wagered £52. The company’s winnings on those stakes – shown as revenue in financial accounts released this week – were £2. It had an operating profit of £682m, meaning it has a staggering profit margin of 25%, far higher than traditional bookmakers saddled with the fixed cost of high

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Bitcoin and online poker Bitcoin and online poker The house edge is in every form of commercial gambling and means that the more you play over …
Bitcoin and online poker Bitcoin and online poker The house edge is in every form of commercial gambling and means that the more you play over time, the more you will lose, bitcoin and online poker. How Zeroedge Online Casino
If you need a bonus code, it is mentioned here. Otherwise, just go to the sites through the links on this page and the bonuses are granted automatically, crypto poker club rake. Betting site Bonus Features Go to site. Wagering: 5x the deposit in accumulator bets. http://mkttransport.co.uk/community/profile/casinobtc6810061/ The only disadvantage of the platform is that it is not available globally. It is unique in a way that it protects cryptocurrency users; it offers you the

BIO: Our newest member: paulinastretch Tags
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





In what looks like one of the biggest moves into crypto in 2019, Symbiont Inc got a $20 million cash injection from a Nasdaq-led funding round.Even though this is one of Nasdaq’s most pronounced …
In what looks like one of the biggest moves into crypto in 2019, Symbiont Inc got a $20 million cash injection from a Nasdaq-led funding round.Even though this is one of Nasdaq’s most pronounced moves into crypto, they are not unfamiliar with digital assets. Some months ago, the Wall

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Meme cryptocurrency dogecoin (DOGE) has soared in January 2021, demonstrating the power of investor sentiment in financial markets.
2021 has been a year …
Meme cryptocurrency dogecoin (DOGE) has soared in January 2021, demonstrating the power of investor sentiment in financial markets.
2021 has been a year
Over the past month or so, the cryptocurrency has witnessed stellar price growth outperforming nearly every other asset in the market.
At the end of December 2020, dogecoin was trading for a mere $0.004. Only a month later, each token is trading for around $0.08. That represents a nearly 2,000% appreciation, which is pretty much unheard of even in volatile crypto markets.
Dogecoin’s buying pressure has become too big to ignore, with daily trading volumes routinely peaking above $10 billion as well.
So how did dogecoin go from being a meme currency to dominating the news cycle alongside bitcoin and ethereum (ETH)? Will this particular cryptocurrency continue to see skyrocketing valuations throughout 2021?
Launched in 2013, dogecoin got its name from the then-popular “doge” meme involving images of a Shiba Inu. This is also why the official mascot and logo of the digital currency prominently feature the Japanese dog.
The biggest criticism of dogecoin has always been that it follows an inflationary policy. Traditional cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin have a fixed supply preventing inflation commonly seen in fiat currencies. For context, the supply of dogecoin is infinite, while there will only ever be 21 million BTC in total.
Dogecoin already has approximately 128 billion coins in circulation, with more expected to flow in over time. This is also why the cryptocurrency’s market capitalization is in the billions despite its low, sub-$1 price point.
Dogecoin’s recent price movements aside, its community has gone a long way towards making the token usable as a currency.
Back when bitcoin was released in 2009, crypto enthusiasts envisioned a future where money would be decentralized. By decoupling wealth from the state apparatus, Satoshi Nakamoto hoped to steer the world away from yet another economic crisis.
Over a decade later, and bitcoin has strayed away from its founding goal of serving as a peer-to-peer (P2P) transfer of value. These days, the asset is mostly regarded as an excellent store of value. The institutions that bitcoin sought to overthrow are now investing in it — as a hedge against fiat currencies such as the United States dollar.
Dogecoin, on the other hand, is still an asset that can be used to complete user and merchant transactions. Even better, dogecoin can do that for cheap, while cryptocurrencies such as BTC and ETH now have exorbitant fees.
In other words, DOGE has gone from being a satirical take on finance to an actual, usable cryptocurrency.
According to Cryptwerk, over a thousand merchants already accept payments in dogecoin for various goods and services. In contrast, around 6,000 merchants are known to accept payments in bitcoin. Still, dogecoin’s rise from a meme currency to one of utility is proof that anything is possible with a coordinated community.
Most of dogecoin’s recent success comes at the behest of individual investors. This is unlike more mainstream cryptocurrencies, which have attracted significant investments from Wall
Indeed, retail investors banding together is a phenomenon that appears to be increasingly commonplace. In January 2021, share prices of video
The GameStop situation was a unique scenario wherein large hedge funds had shorted the stock to oblivion. By betting against the company, these funds expected to make money as share prices fell.
Once Reddit’s r/WallStreetBets (WSB) community got wind of the situation, its users began aggressively buying up all available shares. This pushed GameStop’s stock price upwards, forcing hedge funds and traditional finance firms to swallow an unprecedented loss.
The WSB community caught the attention (and ire) of almost every entity operating on Wall
Over the course of a single month, r/WallStreetBets gained six million readers, totaling a staggering eight million.
Even though dogecoin does not carry significant short interest capital, many retail investors are hoping for a similar success story as GameStop. Armed with nothing more than positive sentiment, the dogecoin community claims it is ready to shed the “meme coin” moniker.
r/SatoshiStreetBets, a subreddit pitched as the crypto equivalent of r/WallStreetBets, has amassed over 300,000 subscribers. Throughout January 2021, the vast majority of discussions within that community involved dogecoin in one way or another. For proof of their conviction and loyalty to dogecoin, look no further than some of the most popular content on the subreddit.
One user loudly proclaimed:
“It [Doge] will become the currency of the internet.”
The post continued:
“You need to understand that DOGE coin is not a joke anymore, and it has a great future and is currently backed by the biggest influencers. If bitcoin becomes an alternative for gold as a way to store money, DOGE could become the internet currency by excellence!”
The post went on to garner over 1,300 upvotes, at the time of writing.
While WallStreetBets exploded in popularity only recently, dogecoin has been steadily gaining momentum for several months, if not years. With DOGE, users have an established platform that can be used for good and create an economy free of central banks and hedge funds. Even though WSB has attracted millions, the community does not have the tools necessary to create a decentralized economy.
Creating a cryptocurrency is no tall ordeal — after all, there are now over 8,000 of them on the market. Maintaining one and generating enough hype to be a top ten digital currency by market cap, on the other hand, is a feat only dogecoin has achieved. Starting from scratch is not an option for WSB, which is perhaps why many have chosen DOGE as their preferred asset.
Whether or not dogecoin enables wider crypto adoption, it has already succeeded in bringing public attention to the cryptocurrency market. In fact, the community has managed to hold its own for several years now.
In 2014, for instance, a Reddit user successfully managed to convince the dogecoin community to sponsor a NASCAR
Another time, the dogecoin community organized a fundraiser aimed at providing service dogs to special needs children. This Doge4Kids campaign reached its 20 million DOGE goal by September 2015.
In yet another instance of community service, the Dogecoin Foundation raised $50,000 to build two wells in Kenya. The African country was suffering from a severe drought and multi-year water crisis, at the time.
Thanks to its highly approachable premise and philanthropic efforts, dogecoin has grown in popularity as a people’s cryptocurrency. Indeed, the cryptocurrency community has always pushed for democratization of wealth. What remains to be seen, however, is if dogecoin can fulfill the condition of sound money.
So far this year, dogecoin has experienced far greater volatility than any other cryptocurrency. Even then, most long-term DOGE holders are looking at a net gain as long as their entry point was in 2020 or prior.
An important factor to consider is the fact that dogecoin’s recent price action was not motivated by a singular Reddit group alone. Elon Musk, of Tesla and SpaceX fame, has taken a newfound interest in dogecoin.
Musk’s barrage of dogecoin-related tweets began in late 2020. On Dec. 20, 2020, he simply tweeted, “One word: Doge.” These three words were enough to spark a 40% price bump for the cryptocurrency.
In a later statement on Jan. 31, Musk acknowledged that some of his past dogecoin comments were made in jest. Nevertheless, he continued:
“The most entertaining outcome and the most ironic outcome would be that dogecoin becomes the currency of Earth in the future.”
By Feb. 6, 2021, Musk was back at it. He encouraged his Twitter followers to vote for “The future currency of Earth.” The only two options were “Dogecoin to the Moooonn” and “All other crypto combined.”
Musk is not the only high profile billionaire that has spoken favorably about dogecoin of late. Mark Cuban, famed tech entrepreneur, said that he would pick dogecoin over a lottery ticket.
Then, on Feb. 7, rap artist Snoop Dogg tweeted out an image of dogecoin’s mascot with the caption “Snoop Doge.” The rapper also tagged Musk, reaching millions of Twitter users between the two accounts. This event was enough stimulus to pump dogecoin to a new all-time high of $0.0872.
Snoop Dogg’s tweet was also enough to propel dogecoin to the list of the top ten cryptocurrencies by market capitalization. With a valuation of over $10 billion, the token briefly became more valuable than litecoin (LTC) and bitcoin cash (BCH).
CoinMarketCap, a cryptocurrency price aggregation platform, also joined in on the dogecoin humor. The website now prominently features dogecoin’s price and recent movements at the top instead of a more typical market-wide summary.
Then, Tesla revealed that it had been silently scooping up bitcoin throughout January 2021. With a portfolio amounting to a whooping $1.5 billion, Tesla’s stake in the world’s largest cryptocurrency sparked a new rally for the entire market. Bitcoin’s price rose by 22% over 12 hours, peaking at $47,500 — a new all-time high.
Unfortunately for dogecoin investors though, Tesla did not purchase any cryptocurrency other than bitcoin. Nevertheless, news of the company embracing the asset class sent dogecoin prices soaring as well — allowing it to breach the $0.085 price point again. A few hours later, Musk was back on Twitter — this time, to post an “instructional video” on dogecoin.
On Feb. 10, however, Musk confirmed his DOGE purchase, though how much he has bought remains unclear.
With support for dogecoin pouring in from all facets of the world, it appears to be only a matter of time before the community realizes its target of $0.1 per DOGE. Still, for many within the dogecoin community, this will not be a victory. To them, the cryptocurrency is worth much more than its price alone.
On Feb. 8, dogecoin creator Billy Markus, published an open letter on Reddit denouncing the recent mania surrounding the coin. He stated:
“People are talking about dogecoin going to $1 — that would make the ‘market cap’ larger than actual companies that provide services to millions, such as Boeing, Starbucks, American Express, IBM. Does dogecoin deserve that? That is not something I can comprehend, let alone answer,”.
Two years after creating dogecoin, Markus quit working on the project in 2015. He claims to have liquidated his entire dogecoin holdings at the time, which was only enough to “buy a used Honda Civic.”
Markus somberly concluded:
“Joy, kindness, learning, giving, empathy, fun, community, inspiration, creativity, generosity, silliness, absurdity. These types of things are what makes dogecoin worthwhile to me. If the community embodies these things, that’s True Value,”
Rahul Nambiampurath is an India-based Digital Marketer who got attracted to Bitcoin and the blockchain in 2014. Ever since, he's been an active member of the community. He has a Masters degree in Finance. <a href="mailto:editorinchief@beincrypto.com">Email me!</a>
BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Despite the health crisis that engulfed nearly all parts of the world amid the Covid-19 pandemic, the crypto industry remained still and intact. However, the pandemic dominated the news in 2020 …
Despite the health crisis that engulfed nearly all parts of the world amid the Covid-19 pandemic, the crypto industry remained still and intact. However, the pandemic dominated the news in 2020 due to its malicious damage across major sectors. The health sector, economy, social justice, politics, cross-border trade were among the highly affected.
Federal governments across many nations imposed lockdowns and curfew to mitigate the spread of the virus and as well offering stimulus package to safeguard their falling economies. Although prevention measures were necessary, those measures raised the rate of global inflation. In that context, the move pushed many traditional investors and institutions to seek an alternate store of value
That is where the cryptocurrency and blockchain sectors thrived. Bitcoin and other top cryptos seemed less affected. Also, the technology stocks helped salvage the failing traditional markets to the benefit of the global economy.
Following the March 11, 2020 dip, BTC started its journey to glory reaching its then record high by the end of the year. Below is a recap of the hot stories that dominated the cryptocurrency and the blockchain world in 2020.
The largest seeded and world’s oldest cryptocurrency attained record highs close to the end of the year. Bitcoin circulating trading cap surpassed $500B moving higher above top-seeded investment platforms like VISA and Berkshire Hathaway. However, Bitcoin price neared the $30,000 mark before the year ends.
Since then, Bitcoin has exploded higher reaching highs of just under $38,500 as of January 7, 2021 and its market cap is hovering above $680 billion. If it continues with this momentum, it will soon overtake Tesla and Facebook in the market capitalization charts heading towards $1 trillion.
The year 2020 was different compared to pre-rally in 2017. In December 2017, Asian traders joining the crypto industry pushed Bitcoin to record an all-time high of $19,850. Nonetheless, the Year 2020 thing was different as many bitcoin l“whales” and institutions flocked to the industry to accumulate more holdings.
In a crypto review done by the New York Times, many mature investors were continuously purchasing increments of Bitcoin and often holding it off-chain for long-term investment. The New York Times cited:
“We’re seeing fresh stories about institutional crypto adoption almost a daily basis at this point.”
Brandon Mintz, Bitcoin Depot CEO, in mid-December hinted that MicroStrategy, Square, Paul Tudor Jones, MassMutual, PayPal, Guggenheim Investors, and several insurance company were among those purchasing BTC in 2020. Brandon said:
“We are being driven by corporations and billionaires now not just retailers.”
The amount locked in decentralized finance (DeFi) soared nearly four times by the end of the year 2020. The co-founder of Smart Economy Network, Da Hongfe, stated that last year was unequivocally the year of DeFi which somewhat was true. Da Hongfe highlighted:
“2020 was unequivocally the year of decentralized finance”
According to data compiled by DeFi Pulse, the amount of locked-in decentralized finance surged threefold to almost $15 Billion on December 30, compared with only $658 million at the beginning of the year.
In that context, a new term “yield farming “entered the crypto lexicon. interestingly, in return for staking BTC or Ether(ETH) as collateral with DeFi firm, participants were set to get a governance token that lets the holder debate or vote in matters connected to protocol change.
Nevertheless, the ownership of governance tokens became increasingly lucrative in 2020. In June 2020, Compound (COMP) was launched and issued in the market. COMP surged in value from $61 at its launch to $382 on June 21 following endorsement by United States-based crypto exchange, Coinbase. COMP closed the year at $148 on December 31, 2020.
According to one professor at the Stevens Institute of Technology, Giuseppe Ateniese, Decentralized Finance stood as a “
“with decentralized finance, there’s no human in the loop, no server, no organization. There’s no bias”
Unlike the traditional bank car loan, where the borrower defaults, the bank goes to seek for the car repossession, he explained:
“With the DeFi, assets are digital and locked/committed through smart contracts. If you don’t pay the loan back, the digital asset that was used as collateral is taken, and there is nothing I can do about it”
PayPal’s participation in the crypto space attracted a huge positive sentiment that has dominated the sector ever since. It took Bitcoin 12 years to gain 100 million users. Interestingly, in a single month, the network added a potential 300 million users after PayPal announced its partnership. PayPal announced that it would allow its users to buy, sell and hold Bitcoin, Ether, Bitcoin Cash (BCH|), and Litecoin (LTC).
In November 2020, Pantera Capital also announced that the impact from the partnership between PayPal and crypto was evident within weeks. Pantera updated:
“Within four weeks of going live, PayPal is already buying almost 70% of the new supply of Bitcoins”
Later, in the following month, Pantera hinted that PayPal had maximized its buy option by more than 100%. Pantera updated:
“within two months of going live, PayPal is already buying more than 100% of the new supply of Bitcoins.”
Bitcoin halving is fairly important. Since its development, the BTC halving was designed to limit the issuance rate of new coins to mitigate inflation in the Bitcoin market. Notably, Bitcoin is capped at 21 million units that are released gradually and their supply rare is halved roughly after every four years.
The analogous of a company telling its employees that it will issue a 50% pay cut is a perfect example of Bitcoin halving. The incentives given to network validators “miners” are sliced by half.
May 2020 saw the halving event that reduced miner’s incentives from 12.5 BTC to 6. 25 BTC. In that incident, the halving came and went causing no impact on the miners or collapse in the network’s computing power “hash rate” as many had feared. But, seven months down the line, Bitcoin was selling at almost three times higher compared to its pre-halving level of $8,566 recorded on May 11.
After the DeFi industry became more competitive, Central banks thought of challenging the DeFi ecosystem. The
Although many expected China’s digital currency electronic payments project would soon achieve
“China rapid development of central bank digital currency has the potential to upset global monetary order”
According to United States Federal Reserve chief, Jerome Powell, the rush to launch a central bank digital currency (CBDC) was irresponsible since matters such as cyber-attacks and fraud prevention were not prioritized.
However, if China will not have the world’s first CBDC, the distinction belongs to the Bahamas, an island that made history in October 20 with its digital currency built on blockchain platform and it is known as the Sand Dollar.
In 2020, the number of corporations and institutional investors joining the crypto space was at hype. The biggest independent publicly-traded intelligence company, MicroStrategy, led the institutional investment brigade. In August 2020, MicroStrategy had accumulated $250 million worth of bitcoin.
Amid the Covid-19 pandemic, a majority of the investors found refuge in Bitcoin as a dependable store of value. Furthermore, the increasing government stimulus measures undertaken to combat the economic impact of the Covid-19 health crisis was at a high. These efforts were expected to harm the value of fiat currencies according to Michael Saylor, the MicroStrategy CEO. He commented:
“Significant depreciating effect on the long-term real value of fiat currencies and many other conventional asset types, including those traditionally held as part of corporate treasury operations”
Michael further gained the confidence to endorse Bitcoin as a dependable store of value. He added:
“In this new world, Bitcoin is a dependable store of value, with more long term appreciation potential than holding cash”
MicroStrategy continued to acquire more Bitcoin. The company raised $650 million through the sale of convertible notes to buy more Bitcoin. In December 2020, MicroStrategy had a cumulative of 70,470 BTC, purchased at $15,964 per Bitcoin on average. The move attracted some attention to the Wall
“Is this a publicly-traded company or it’s a hedge fund?”
In December 2020, Coinbase crypto exchange announced its ambitious bid to become the first crypto-native corporation to be listed on a major U.S stock exchange through an in initial public offering (IPO).
According to the research firm Messari, if Coinbase manages to get listed, the 35-million customers’ company value could be $28 billion. St. Gotthard Fund Management AG, the director and co-founder of Swiss wealth management firm, endorsed the Coinbase bid. He said:
“It’s a massive event because the IPO will provide the marker in terms of how markets are ready to value such companies.”
Notably, this IPO is a milestone for the crypto industry. In that context, it was far from clear, whether the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) would have signed off the arrangement. Coinbase stirred controversy somewhat in 2020 by discouraging its employee from political activism in the workplace which was at a peak.
In November 2020, the New York Times reported that some Coinbase black employees had voiced their worries about discriminatory treatment. Others noted that the exchange was still plagued by untimely service outages during the times of price volatility.
John Griffin, a professor at the University of Texas Finance cited that, the IPO announcement was a major event. He stated:
“showing that the path of Coinbase ton work within the regulatory process is an economically profitable one.”
Earlier, Telegram Group Inc. has sought to build a decentralized blockchain platform along the design of Bitcoin and Ethereum. According to Pavel Durov, the founder and CEO of the open-source encrypted messenger service firm, this project was set to be widely superior to bitcoin and Ethereum in matters related to speed and scalability.
Telegram had 300 million users globally but failed to overcome the resistance from the SEC and abandoned its project TON (Telegram Open Network) in May 2020. Although that project was well-strategized, with the Dubai-based firm raising around $1.7 billion to launch “Gram token”, the SEC deemed the coin as an unregistered security and moved to stop their distribution in the United States and anywhere else around the world.
After the SEC rejected that project, Durov seemed to console himself. He stated:
“We are still dependent on the United States when it comes to finance and technology, but this may change in the future. But today, we are in a vicious circle: you can’t bring more balance to an overly centralized world exactly because it’s so centralized.”
Telegram attracted participation from several prominent investors, including blue-chip venture capital firm Kleiner Perkins and Sequoia Capital.
In 2020, High profile billionaire, Paul Tudor Jones endorsed Bitcoin. His move came after the COVID-19 Pandemic-related stimulus efforts attracted worries among most of the investors.
While the federal government was seeking ways to safeguard their plunging economies, high-profile billionaires pledged to invest in cryptos and gave the nascent space a fresh view as an alternate store of value.
In May 2020, prominent billionaire Paul Tudor hinted that a portion of his asset portfolio was invested in Bitcoin. Bitwise Asset Management revealed that the endorsement of a celebrated investor like Jones who predicted a stock market crash in 1987 paved the way for mainstream investors and institutions to join the crypto sector. Bitwise representative, David Lawant said:
“Making the Case for Bitcoin as his preferred hedge against what Jones calls ‘the great monetary inflation’ has significantly reduced ‘career risk ‘for many of his peers considering an allocation to Bitcoin.”
The Wall
“The (Bitcoin) rally has attracted a wide cast of characters, from the Wall
Earlier in December 2020, Ripple engaged in a lawsuit with SEC after denouncing XRP as a security. The XRP was the third-biggest cryptocurrency by market value trailing behind Bitcoin and Ether.
The SEC, led by outgoing chairman Jay Clayton, filed legal action against Ripple and its top-executives. SEC alleged that the XRP coin created by Ripple was created as a security, and the firm raised over $1.3 billion through unregistered, ongoing digital asset securities offering. In that context, three days after the announcement, XRP price plummeted by 41%, and it became unclear whether the San-Francisco-based firm will survive that lawsuit.
On December 27, Ripple’s problems worsened after Coinbase, the largest stock market exchange announced that it would suspend XRP trading. Coinbase claimed that the climate around the coin had become increasingly unbearable. Similarly, on December 27, the largest digital asset management firm Grayscale investments reportedly liquidated more than $9.18 million in XRP.
Nevertheless, Ripple denounced the SEC’s action as “an attack on the entire crypto industry here in the United States “as the firm CEO Brad Garlinghouse stated that he would continue to support Ripple’s customer base in the United States and globally.
The number of corporations and institutional investors seeking an alternate store of value is actively growing. In that connection, the crypto space will continue to shine as it happened in 2020 amid the pandemic.
While the health crisis continues to take a downward trend amid vaccine rollouts in various nations, elsewhere blockchain innovations continue to thrive on several fronts, including decentralized finance and CBDC development.
In the United States, fingers remain crossed on digital token expansion following SEC lawsuit against XRP and Telegram’s TON. Interestingly, the awaited administration transition, including SEC leadership hopefully will bring more regulatory clarity in crypto in 2021.

BIO: John is a content crafter and has experience in writing Forex and Crypto news for FXTimes for over a year. He is also an experienced creative and technical writer, and is usually one of the first ones to publish, discover or cover a scoop. e-mail: john@fxtimes.com
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





into all of that. So, in 2013, I was working on something called color coins on Bitcoin. And this is what you might call photo Ethereum ICO stuff. And it was on the Bitcoin protocol, you could buy …
into all of that. So, in 2013, I was working on something called color coins on Bitcoin. And this is what you might call photo Ethereum ICO stuff. And it was on the Bitcoin protocol, you could buy coins that are “colored” so you can trade them as assets that are other than Bitcoin, something like that. So that was where… That was sort of my first experience doing open source development on Bitcoin related projects. And one of the people that we had actually writing the white paper for color coins was Vitalik Buterin, and he actually wrote the white paper. It wasn’t what we had written.
Jimmy Song (00:48:56): So there was a little bit of back and forth, and he said, “You know what, I’m not going to change the white paper to say what you wanted it to say.” It’s like, but that’s what it is technically. And he’s like, “I’m not going to do it.” And it’s like, “Okay.” He’s like, “I think I’m going to go make my own coin anyway.” So that coin, of course, ended up being Ethereum, and that he launched maybe three months later with yellow paper and a white paper. And he did the crowd fundraising in early 2014, and so on. Now, at the time, this was my assessment of Ethereum just given sort of the ambitions that he had for it. First, he wanted Turing complete scripting language.
Preston Pysh (00:49:38): Why? Because when I look at what Adam Back’s doing with Simplicity, isn’t it the polar opposite of that?
Jimmy Song (00:49:46): It is, and he wanted Turing completeness. He thought that was a weakness of the Bitcoin smart contract language script, but Satoshi specifically made it not Turing complete because you could DDoS all nodes with an infinite loop. And as soon as you have Turing completeness, you just have… You just put out an infinite loop out there, and this is why Ethereum has such complicated mechanics like the idea of gas. It’s so that you can have infinite loops. Every time you run through a loop you use up some gas, and if you run out of gas too bad. This is why if your transaction doesn’t go through on Ethereum you lose your fees anyway. This is one of the subtle gotchas. The thing is Vitalik has this reputation as some sort of prodigy or whatever.
Preston Pysh (00:50:36): You didn’t see it.
Jimmy Song (00:50:37): Yeah, I mean, I’m just a coder, right? I’ve been coding since I was nine, but professionally for 23 years or something like that. And I gotta say, I’ve looked at his code. And the thing is he started as a 19 year old getting into Bitcoin. And then he did Ethereum and all that, and everyone has this incentive to make him out to be this child prodigy genius, or whatever. Thing is what I see is a kid that doesn’t really know how to code well as a programmer, right?
Preston Pysh (00:51:14): You just have no experience at that age.
Jimmy Song (00:51:16): Yeah, exactly.
Preston Pysh (00:51:17): You don’t have 20, 30 years of experience. So, how could you?
Jimmy Song (00:51:21): Yeah, and I look at Ethereum, and I see all these flaws. Initially, like Ethereum addresses, simple example. But Bitcoin addresses they’re base 58, at least on Tibet 32. If you’re using native SegWit then that’s something else. But Bitcoin addresses are base 58. The last five or six characters are what you call the checksum. So, it makes sure that if you wrote it down wrong, or you pasted it something wrong in that address, any wallet can easily detect it and say, “You know what, this is you pasted it wrong, or maybe did something wrong. Can you check again, and make sure you get the right address? That’s just good practice. If you didn’t have just the checksum, and you wrote the wrong thing then it’ll go somewhere else and you’ll lose those coins, and the person won’t receive them. So, that’s just good engineering. That’s what you would call something, you make it hard for the user to do the wrong.
Jimmy Song (00:52:26): Ethereum, they had this brilliant idea, we’re going to ditch base 58, and we’re going to use hexadecimal and all our addresses are going to start with zero x. They took out the checksum. So what happens? Lots of people put the wrong address in and they just burn their Ethereum. So they obviously recognized their mistake, but there are all sorts of things like that throughout the entire thing. [crosstalk 00:52:52]. Vitalik to me is sort of like that, and I’ve seen this. I’ve managed college kids that came out, and work for me in different capacities or whatever. And the typical sort of mentality of somebody that comes out of college, maybe they study software engineering in college is they just want to use something cool and do something new or whatever.
Jimmy Song (00:53:16): Vitalik almost exactly fits that profile to a tee, right? His mentality is, if it’s not built yet, I want to make my own because I think I can make it better. He kind of has that. And the result is usually that’s something that’s a complete mess. And this is in stark contrast to Satoshi’s choices. Almost all of Satoshi’s choices in creating the Bitcoin protocol is take some standard that already existed instead of trying to roll your own crypto, which unfortunately is what Vitalik seems to have done with everything Ethereum related. And this is why Solidity is such a mess, and it has so many security flaws. And it’s very difficult to analyze, and you don’t know what’s going on, and you’re not sure how long it will run. It’s just a giant mess.
Preston Pysh (00:54:06): At the heart of it for me is going back to a conversation that you and I had earlier, which is about this governance. This
Jimmy Song (00:54:46): You don’t have a vote whatsoever.
Preston Pysh (00:54:48): You don’t have a vote.
Jimmy Song (00:54:49): The thing about Ethereum is that they hard fork every six months or whenever they need to because [crosstalk 00:54:55], and their hard fork is essentially backwards incompatible. This is sort of built in so that the Ethereum Foundation and the Ethereum developers will have all the power perpetually, forever. This was I think one of the early things that happened to Ethereum was the “DAO hack.” It wasn’t so much a hack as it was more like good smart contract war. But essentially what had happened was you had this thing called the DAO which was supposed to be a Decentralized Autonomous Organization where the crowd would decide where the fund would invest.
So, it was sort of like a crowdfunded VC fund or something like that, and that was the idea behind it. But of course, the contracts were written wrong, and somebody figured out how to drain it of all its money. And basically they did. And then they decided, “Oh, you know what,” I think at the time, one sixth of all Ethereum was in the DAO contract. So they decided, “Okay, it’s getting drained of all this money. We’re going to roll that back.”
Preston Pysh (00:55:56): When you say they, you’re saying the Ethereum Foundation.
Jimmy Song (00:55:59): Yeah, essentially, it was Vitalik.I still remember to this day what Vitalik said the week before he made that decision. Or not Vitalik, but other people in the Ethereum community were saying before the decision. There was a guy that was literally on YouTube saying, “I would understand if Vitalik decided that code is law, and that he would let this go. I would also understand if he decided to roll it back,” which tells me there was no principle here. It was just, let’s just follow our dear leader into whatever he wants to do.
And of course, a week later, he decided, “Okay, we’re going to roll all those transactions back, and that caused what was at that time known as that Ethereum-Ethereum Classic split. The Ethereum Classic node operators were basically saying, “You know what, we think code is law, and we’re going to keep going with it.” Barry Silbert bought into that soon afterwards, and he’s I think pretty much the only one that pumps it at this point.
Jimmy Song (00:56:56): That proved that Vitalik controls the entire Ethereum ledger. He said, all of these spends to that contract, we’re going to just roll them back. We’re going to pretend they didn’t happen. I mean, this is nothing different than a government bailout of an industry. That’s essentially what Ethereum did. There’s no reason to think that he wouldn’t do it again, if it was sufficiently harmful to Ethereum not do so.
Preston Pysh (00:57:25): And just for the record, if somebody will… I think we just had the example. I’ve been seeing the article the last two days or whatever. This person who lost their private keys on their computer, and I think it’s $100 million or more, or something like that. It’s not like any one person can roll that back no matter what with Bitcoin. It’s impossible.
Jimmy Song (00:57:48): It is. It is impossible because it’s a bearer instrument. And somebody told me that the last 50 years of US policy has been getting rid of bearer instruments and Bitcoin is kind of bringing them back. Yeah, the reason why they’ve been taking it away is because then they can have their hands in the middle of it. And they can be the intermediary that can control you financially. With Bitcoin, you get that back with Ethereum, you don’t have that at all because you have this intermediary, a central party that can do whatever the heck they want. But with Bitcoin, you lose your keys, it’s losing the 400 ounce gold bar that you had in your safe or buried in your backyard and forgot where it is, you’re not getting it back.
Jimmy Song (00:58:32): It’s both sort of a thrilling prospect because you’re your own bank, but it’s also a scary prospect because you’re your own bank because people are not used to taking custody of their own stuff, or having that much responsibility. We’re used to outsourcing it to trusted third parties, which, in a sense, I can kind of understand it makes it more difficult for certain types of attacks, but it makes you way more vulnerable to another type of attack, which is that the government can take it away. That’s horrible.
Preston Pysh (00:59:04): Yeah, shut down or manipulate it or whatever. All right, real fast. Talk to us about what Uniswap is, and then talk to us about your thoughts on just decentralized lending, and things like that moving forward with Bitcoin, specifically.
Jimmy Song (00:59:22): Uniswap is what they call a DeFi platform and-
Preston Pysh (00:59:28): Decentralized finance.
Jimmy Song (00:59:30): Yeah, which I think is a misnomer because it’s anything but decentralized. Because you have the Uniswap token issuers and the Uniswap contract writers, and they have back doors, and all this other stuff, and who knows. But basically, it’s a platform for some sort of lending or whatever, and you have different assets on there. For some reason, they’re named after lots of different foods. But essentially, you have different ways in which you can collateralize your Bitcoin or Ethereum or whatever. You have to wrap it in an Ethereum contract and of course that Bitcoin is held by BitGo, but it’s wrapped so you have some guarantees. It’s the worst thing to call it decentralized because it’s centralized at six different points. It’s not decentralized at all.
Jimmy Song (01:00:20): It’s more like anonymous finance or something like that, or pseudonymous finance, because you just put up the collateral and you get the loan and you can, I don’t know, maybe go buy more of Ethereum or more of whatever and that’s how most people use it is some way to leverage it. And as a result you have this platform for doing some, playing financial
Preston Pysh (01:00:58): I’m looking at [inaudible 01:00:59] because the whole yield farming, I mean, it’s just a total scam, right? My thing that I’m looking at it more from is the technology of using an exchange, basically decentralizing an exchange. And even though this particular example with Uniswap, and you’re saying that it’s centralized, I agree with you. Is there a way to do this in a way that would be decentralized in the future? Let’s say we’re five, 10 years from now, is this something that the engineering can actually catch up to? And is this something that could actually be applied to the Bitcoin blockchain protocol?
Jimmy Song (01:01:36): Here’s the difficult thing, and this is what you always end up at when you talk about smart contracts is something called the Oracle problem. And the Oracle problem is that almost anything interesting requires some information from the real world. Whether or not a house changed hands or that it legally… Something happened in the real world, the score of a baseball
Preston Pysh (01:02:00): So this would be a good one, the weather. Everyone wants to do futures contracts based on the way that the weather was reported, right?
Jimmy Song (01:02:08): Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Preston Pysh (01:02:08): And so, if it was between 50 [crosstalk 01:02:12]-
Jimmy Song (01:02:11): You need an Oracle. You need somebody to add that data to the smart contract. Now, there are many ways to do that. But all of them are essentially centralized on that Oracle because the Oracle needs to report truthfully, and you have no guarantees that they will. I mean, you can try to say, “Okay, well, then use 10 Oracles and the majority, we’ll listen to the majority.” Well, there’s no guarantees that there are, first of all, 10 different entities. And second of all, that they won’t collude with each other. You have no idea. So you get into these weird situations with all of this where you still have to trust the third party. And when you’re asking for something decentralized, what you’re asking for is no trusted third party. That is essentially what you’re asking. And from a metaphysical standpoint, it’s not even at the layer of engineering, you can’t get away from that.
Jimmy Song (01:03:03): If it has anything to do with the real world in any way, shape, or form it cannot even in principle be a decentralized thing because of the external data that you need. Now, within an ecosystem, so even like price based contracts or something like that on Bitcoin, right? You still need somebody to say that Bitcoin exchange for this many dollars on this day on this exchange. That’s data that needs to come in from the outside. So I have a hard time… Unless it’s purely digital and it’s like, okay, blocks will be found within or difficulty will be this. And the next difficulty adjustment are something that’s within the Bitcoin ecosystem that you can sort of measure without trusting a third party to report data from outside the blockchain. It’s in principle impossible because it requires some trust on something.
Preston Pysh (01:03:59): When I think about my experience in financial markets over the last 20 years, there’s never been a situation where I’ve said to myself, I wish this exchange was decentralized. I wish that these stock certificates that I’m buying or this derivatives exchange that I’m using the buy call options was decentralized. Never. I’ve never had a need for that. Sure, the fees could be lower. But I mean, look at Robin Hood right now, there’s no fees for any of it. Now, they’re selling the data to make some money. But at the end of the day, I just don’t have when you go to the fundamental route, what is the problem that we’re solving for society? Where’s the value capture that we’re adding that the customer isn’t getting right now? I just don’t see what problem you’re solving. When I look at Bitcoin.
Preston Pysh (01:04:49): My issue that Bitcoin solves is like you and I talked about last week when we were talking about the whole valuation process. You can’t conduct a valuation on something if the unit you’re using, you’re getting the base that’s 15 or 20% annually. You’re using ruler that’s a Gumby ruler that’s changing by the day. And so, I guess when I look at the heart of what it is Ethereum, Uniswap like we’re just talking about, I just can’t wrap my head around what the problem is that they’re solving. It just seems like they’ve discovered all this neat tech. They’ve discovered this massive influx of capital that people are just willingly throwing at it because it’s effectively coming from the problem that I was just describing that Bitcoin is solving.
Preston Pysh (01:05:36): And so, I think you have this really interesting scenario where you got a lot of engineers who might not be looking at the big picture of what is the problem that we’re solving. But they’re able to play with a bunch of levers and a bunch of gears and a bunch of code. And they’re having fun, right? It goes back to your description of his personality. And that’s totally reflective in how I see what he’s doing, and what the code is actually doing from a performance standpoint.
Jimmy Song (01:06:05): Yeah, I would say that’s a very accurate description. Essentially, when you have new grads that want to play with new technology, or whatever they kind of get lost. And when they come back with whatever project you gave them, and they come back with this thing, it barely works, it’s not performant. You’re just like, “Okay, go do it again, and use the tech stack that I told you.” They learn that way. With something like Ethereum, Uniswap, all that they don’t have that feedback loop because they get a new injection of money by printing their own money. They’ll create a new token for some reason. And then they sell it to investors or whatever, so they get this new influx of cash. So they can play this
Jimmy Song (01:06:55): The unfortunate reality is that there’s a lot of that money and it’s not going away. We can go back to exactly where that money comes from. But they have influx of new cash coming in from retail or VCs or whoever that want them to keep creating these like Rube Goldberg machines that aren’t really doing anything. They’re essentially… The one need that I do think that they are filling is a need to gamble. A lot of people, and we can talk about exactly why that is in this sort of economy. But there’s a lot of people that want to gamble on stuff. This looks like it’s a decent gamble, they might not understand it. But they’re fine buying lots of different lottery tickets and seeing how many of them pay off. That’s the only actual human need that seems to be fulfilled. Nothing actually in the market that people want.
Preston Pysh (01:07:47): You couldn’t explain it any better than a bunch of lottery tickets. Really, I mean, at the end of the day, I think most people approach this and they say, “This is really complex stuff. This is really hard to understand. There’s no way I can understand it all. And therefore what I’m going to do is I’m just going to typical Wall
Jimmy Song (01:08:39): Like sort of psychologically, you know how if people win at a casino, they don’t really feel like they deserved it on the inside. So, they’ll just sort of spend it very freely on stuff that they would never spend their own money on. I think it’s kind of like that with a lot of people that have received money from some sort of government subsidy or whatever. They are spending it on stuff that very frivolously on things that they’d never otherwise would spend on.
Preston Pysh (01:09:07): Yeah, it’s never earned.
Jimmy Song (01:09:08): Yeah, and it’s going towards projects like this that absolutely do not deserve it. That has no value prop. It’s just sort of like gambling vehicles. I’m thinking now that maybe like all coins are a symptom of sort of Fiat disease. It’s one of the ways in which it manifests itself is that people will just sort of gamble and spray and pray or whatever. That’s sort of the style that people tend towards when they don’t know what to do. So yeah, that seems to be the case.
Preston Pysh (01:09:40): That’s why there’s five Louis Vuitton’s inside of Caesars.
Jimmy Song (01:09:45): That’s right. That’s right. Because at least you could come away with a nice bag.
Preston Pysh (01:09:51): Because if you didn’t see the first one, the one that’s four stores down you might see.
Jimmy Song (01:09:55): Yeah. It is hilarious.
Preston Pysh (01:09:59): All right. Last question for you, man. This time has gone so fast. Wow. I’ve really enjoyed this conversation. The last question I got for you is Jack Mallers, his big announcement. I mean, it’s just really exciting to see some of the stuff that’s happening out in the payment space. I’m curious if there’s any other projects from an engineering standpoint that you’re seeing that you’re really excited about, particularly with Bitcoin that you see really playing out in the next three to five years.
Jimmy Song (01:10:27): I really liked Jack’s project. I always thought Strike was revolutionary for the fact that it can convert Fiat to Bitcoin within that transaction of customer to merchant. It’s almost like every other merchant that’s “taken Bitcoin” has gone the other way. Like somebody will pay in Bitcoin and then the merchant will convert that fiat. And it’s essentially people selling their Bitcoin for goods. And for that reason, most of these companies soon saw their Bitcoin sales dry out very quickly after maybe a little bit of an initial burst, and then they’ll stop taking it because the engineering costs of keeping that on their website would be very high.
Jimmy Song (01:11:09): What Jack’s thing does that’s absolutely brilliant is that for people that want to receive or have no other choice this is perfect because your customer just needs sold dollars, but you receive Bitcoin and you don’t have to convert it in between. So, the customer gets to choose the worst money to spend, but the merchant receives the better money. It’s sort of like subverting Gresham’s law for both parties in a way that works out for both of them. Now, he’s planning to do the same for remittances, which I think is absolutely awesome.
Because if you’re on the other end of remittances, you want the currency that’s going to store value. Because generally you’re in a country that doesn’t have very good stores of value. And you have legal tender laws that make you have to spend your local currency, but no one actually wants to hold it. So if you’re receiving Bitcoin, that’s great. Because now you don’t have to worry about your currency inflating away. And that helps you save, not just on during that transaction, but in other transactions as well. So I think his project is great.
Jimmy Song (01:12:25): But as far as the other ones that I’m excited about, these might sound pretty mundane, but I think they’re significant from a consumer standpoint. One is Specter multisig wallet. So it’s essentially multisig security that is pretty accepted. Use multiple hardware wallets, and so on. I know so many Bitcoin holders that have a single point of failure, and they get nervous as hell about it. And not having a single point of failure is actually very freeing because now even if something goes wrong with one thing, you have backups. You have ways to get around that. That’s always been there. It’s just that the user experience has been kind of terrible. So, now you have a user experience that’s actually doable, and it’s not that hard, and people can set it up themselves. So, that’s one.
Jimmy Song (01:13:15): The other one would be the mentality of dollar-cost averaging, which a lot of exchanges, different apps have put in. This makes investing a lot easier. And from a practical standpoint, I think that will accelerate adoption and get people thinking much more about it. And so, those are the two. I know people want to hear, there’s some space mining project or a Mars thing. But I mean, for me, it’s just making Bitcoin good for what it is, which is a store of value and that means security is important. And that means getting money into the system that you want is important. Both of those things have improved significantly.
Preston Pysh (01:14:01): So Jimmy, you have a new book out. This is called Thank God for Bitcoin. And it is very easy read. You and the other people that assisted in the writing of this, you guys just got straight to the point. And you guys made it in a manner where you’re not trying to impress with your writing, you’re trying to make sure that it’s easily digestible, and you’re hitting the stuff that’s important. That’s what I love about this. So feel free. Just tell people where they can get it. And then anything else that you want to promote or highlight that we can put in the show notes.
Jimmy Song (01:14:37): Thank God for Bitcoin is a book that I wrote with seven other people. It’s kind of a child of COVID. And it started kind of as a book club/Bible study. We studied a couple of books, Ethics of Money Production by Guido Hülsmann and Honest Money by Gary North. Both are books from sort of an Austrian perspective, but talking about the morality of money, and that’s what this book is about. The thing we didn’t like about either of those books was that it didn’t mention Bitcoin. And we wanted to write one that did mentioned Bitcoin, and that made the moral argument for it. And it comes from a Christian perspective, all of us that wrote the book are Christian. But the thing that we wanted to make sure that we got out there is that moral argument because generally people…
Jimmy Song (01:15:22): I mean, you can make the investment case, and people will want to do it out of self-interest, but a moral case is one that causes people to think on another level. If it becomes sort of a moral imperative which we argue that it is in this book, then there’s a way more reason to do it. And it’s not just sort of a selfish endeavor. So you can go buy a Lambo, it’s much more about doing something that’s good for the world, that’s good for civilization and make civilization better. That’s the argument that we make. It’s on Amazon, and you can get that print or Kindle edition. And we’ll have the audiobook out soon. So very exciting stuff.
Preston Pysh (01:16:01): I want to highlight one other thing for folks because anyone listening to this knows you clearly have some programming chops here. Jimmy has another book on Amazon as well that he wrote by himself called Programming Bitcoin, learn how to program Bitcoin from scratch. And having flipped through this book, I’m not a programmer. Having flipped through this book, and it’s over 300 pages long. I don’t know how in the world you could write a book that captures everything that’s going on in… Not everything, but it’s capturing a significant portion of the really important stuff from a coding standpoint. And I know we have people that have an engineering, a computer science background that are listening to this show right now. I just want to make sure that they understand that you have this other book out there as well that I think they might be very interested in.
Jimmy Song (01:16:54): Yeah. So, Programming Bitcoin that’s published by O’Reilly. All of you tech geeks that know about O’Reilly, they make a lot of books on different technical topics and stuff. I was privileged to be able to write that book for them, and it came out of frustration from my early days in Bitcoin where there wasn’t that much documentation. And nobody taught me anything. And I couldn’t find any of the details for anything. So that just as a programmer, this is the resource that I wish I had. And it came as a result of me teaching a lot of different people how to program Bitcoin stuff. And through doing that I understood where people are getting stuck, and so on. It’s a very interactive book, so it has a lot of programming exercises for you to do to make sure that you understand what the heck is going on. So if you don’t understand that, you’re not going to be able to complete the exercise. So you might want to read that part again.
Jimmy Song (01:17:49): It’s meant to be a way for you to really understand everything from a nuts and bolts level. It starts with math, with finite fields and elliptic curves, things that you don’t necessarily learn in high school or college, but they’re not that hard to learn. So I teach those and a lot of programming exercises and then it goes through signatures and public key cryptography and the Bitcoin protocol and of what the anatomy of a transaction block headers and the actual networking aspect and by the end of it, you should be able to connect to the Bitcoin network with your programming, and receive transactions and block headers and so on. That’s what the book is.
Preston Pysh (01:18:34): I just have such a small admiration. I just can’t imagine how long it took you to write this.
Jimmy Song (01:18:38): It took me like 16 months.
Preston Pysh (01:18:40): Wow.
Jimmy Song (01:18:41): It was quite a slog mostly because writing is a lonely endeavor.
Preston Pysh (01:18:46): It’s so true.
Jimmy Song (01:18:49): It’s something that you just… Especially when you’re facing that blank page it’s sort of like an existential dilemma. It’s like, “Do I really exist unless I write something down?” But then you find every excuse imaginable to actually not write words on the page. This is why the other two books that I’ve written Little Bitcoin book and Thank God for Bitcoin, I did it as a group because there’s something about writing with other people and having them depend on you that motivates you way better. That’s how I want to write every other book for the rest of my life is with other people and depending on other people.
Jimmy Song (01:19:26): And part of what you described about Thank God for Bitcoin is that we get to the point. We don’t use flowery language and stuff. It’s because it has eight authors, and we read every page out loud. This was one of the things that we did and if it sounded supercilious or conceited, or something like that people would say so. So would change up the language so that it’s accessible to somebody with like a ninth-grade reading level, and they can understand the arguments we’re making. It’s not necessarily because we’re more virtuous, it’s because we just had a lot more eyes look at it, and you can create something beautiful that way. And that’s something that I learned from startups, and that’s what I brought… I can hopefully bring two books and that’s what I love about it.
Preston Pysh (01:20:11): The thing I’ve learned about writing is the static friction is so much higher than the kinetic friction. It’s just so hard to get started each day.
Jimmy Song (01:20:20): This is why I like writing books with people.
Preston Pysh (01:20:22): Yeah. Yeah, yeah, you’re right. You’re right.
Jimmy Song (01:20:24): The static friction kind of goes away because if the person next to you is writing-
Preston Pysh (01:20:29): Yeah, you feel guilty. All right, Jimmy, man, thank you so much for coming on the show. We have got to do this again. I thoroughly enjoyed this. People, go out, check out the book, Thank God for Bitcoin. Checkout Jimmy also has a podcast, very active on Twitter. Where else can they find you, Jimmy? The spots to hit you up.
Jimmy Song (01:20:50): So, I have a weekly newsletter. That’s sort of the technical developments in Bitcoin that are happening. It’s called the Bitcoin Tech Talk, and it’s at jimmysong.substack.com. And you can go and sign up for my newsletter. You’ll get it in your inbox every Monday. The other thing I have is the podcast like you said, Bitcoin Fixes This. I am on Twitter @jimmysong, GitHub @jimmysong, LinkedIn, Jimmy In/Jimmy Song. So, Medium @jimmysong. I don’t publish too much there anymore because I’m writing this weekly newsletter. But there’s a lot of old articles that might be helpful if you want to understand what happened during SegWit.
Preston Pysh (01:21:30): Jimmy, thanks for coming on the show.
Jimmy Song (01:21:32): Thanks for having me.
Extro (01:21:34): Thank you for listening to TIP. To access our show notes, courses, or forums, go to theinvestorspodcast.com. This show is for entertainment purposes only. Before making any decisions consult a professional. This show is copyrighted by the Investors Podcast Network. Written permissions must be granted before
On today’s show, Preston talks to software engineer and Bitcoin core developer, Jimmy Song. Jimmy covers a wide range of topics on how software is developed, deployed, and updated into the protocol. He also covers risks and concerns that many users of the protocol often voice.
What do you love about our podcast? Here’s our guide on how you can leave a rating and review for the show. We always enjoy reading your comments and feedback!
Preston Pysh (00:00:03): Hey, everyone. Welcome to our Wednesday release of the podcast where I’m covering Bitcoin. Today’s guest is a well-known software engineer and core developer to the Bitcoin protocol, Mr. Jimmy Song. Jimmy has numerous contributions to the current software baseline, and he’s the author of the go to textbook, Programming Bitcoin.
On today’s show, we get into how updates are made to the code, how these updates are tested by a decentralized group of software engineers, then how does the update get deployed? How do
Intro (00:00:53): You are listening to Bitcoin Fundamentals by The Investors Podcast Network. Now for your host, Preston Pysh.
Preston Pysh (00:01:12): All right. So, hey, everyone. Welcome to the show. I’m super pumped to be here with Jimmy Song talking Bitcoin and Bitcoin tech. Jimmy, welcome to the show.
Jimmy Song (00:01:21): Well, thanks for having me. It’s a pleasure to be on. I appreciate that you were on my podcast. So it’s a little nice exchange here.
Preston Pysh (00:01:28): This is fun because we were talking all investing and now we can talk all the tech and engineering and all the really good stuff. So let’s dive into this, Jimmy. Let’s start off. A lot of the folks that listen to our show really kind of come out of traditional finance, and are just getting introduced to Bitcoin for the first time through the show, and you’ve been in this space for years. So, I just want to give the audience a little bit of background on you. So tell us your story. Tell us how you got attracted to Bitcoin. What year was it? Talk to us about some of that stuff.
Jimmy Song (00:02:51): The thing that immediately attracted me was one of the first things I learned, which is that there’s 21 million. And that human instinct, I think, is to collect anything scarce. And as soon as you find out that there’s only 21 million there’s sort of like a tendency to want it, right? This is something that I recognize as sort of inborn. I remember collecting baseball cards when I was little. I still remember, I think it was the Billy Ripken Fleer card that had like a little curse word at the end of the bat. There was only like a small number of them that got printed before they airbrushed that out, or something like that subsequent printings. But that was worth something because it was rare, right? It was scarce.
Jimmy Song (00:03:33): That same instinct, I think sort of caught me when I first learned about Bitcoin in 2011. Of course, I was kind of primed for it because 2008 was when all of the financial stuff was happening. And that led me sort of down a libertarian rabbit hole of what’s going on, why is the system this way? I wouldn’t say that I understood all of what was going on back then. But it gave me enough of an impetus to be open to Bitcoin. And the 10 years since then has been something of a journey and learning the various aspects of Bitcoin, not just programming, which we’re going to talk a lot about, and the technical, but also the economic aspect of it, the social aspect of it, the
Preston Pysh (00:04:17): So, you find out about this, and you see people talking about it online, then you immediately start diving into some of the conversations with some of the people that are working on updates to the code. Is that correct?
Jimmy Song (00:04:29): Well, I didn’t get into actual contribution as a coder until 2013. So it took me a couple years. At that time, it was just sort of like it was so hard to get any information whatsoever in 2011. It was literally just maybe a few websites. Nowadays, you have explainers and YouTube videos and all that stuff. Back then it was literally just like Bitcoin talk forums, and then Mt. Gox. That was about it. It was a guy who had tried to sell Bitcoin for PayPal that I found, but his account was shut down three months before that. So, I obviously couldn’t buy from him. It was difficult even to just get your hands on Bitcoin. At the time you had to… The only way was really Mt. Gox or there was an exchange where they would take a personal check, but that sounded super sketchy to me.
Preston Pysh (00:05:19): So if you bought it on Mt. Gox back in this 2011, 2012 timeframe, were you just keeping it on the exchange because it was too hard to really kind of secure it yourself?
Jimmy Song (00:05:29): Yeah, more or less. So, I had to get it to Dwolla and then do all I had to transfer it to Mt. Gox. And then you could go buy Bitcoin and then if you had your own wallet software, then yeah, you could do it. But there really weren’t that many wallets, right? There was literally the Bitcoin Core wallet, which you had to run like a
Jimmy Song (00:06:15): Oh, man. So that was from a faucet, just people were giving it away. So things have changed significantly. But yeah, I mean, 2013 was when I really got into the coding aspect of it. And that was actually kind of triggered by what you said. My coins were on Mt. Gox at the time, and I had some friends that were telling me, “Hey, you should really get your coins off of Mt. Gox. I’m just hearing some sketchy things going on over there.” And this was summer of 2013.
Jimmy Song (00:06:43): So, I looked into the different wallets and I found Armory, downloaded Armory and put the coins into my Armory wallet. I thought it was very non-performant and stuff, which is ironic because I ended up going and working there a couple years later. But that was how I got my Bitcoin and thank God I did that. Because a few months later Mt. Gox turned out to be insolvent, and they’re still in litigation over getting compensated for the coins that they add on Mt. Gox. So I got it off, and I was very fortunate. I’m very grateful to the friend that told me to take it off.
Preston Pysh (00:07:20): Because I mean back then, I mean, you’re talking, it was not uncommon for a person have thousands of coins on Mt. Gox, thousands, right? Crazy.
Jimmy Song (00:07:29): Easily, thousands. [crosstalk 00:07:30]. There were a lot of people that lost a significant amount of Bitcoin on Mt. Gox because it wasn’t a thing to sort of self custody or people hadn’t learned the lessons. And the thing is, there were other exchanges besides Mt. Gox that had gone bankrupt because they got hacked or something before then and people still didn’t learn. And this is why to tell yourself blessed these days because there’s so many wallets, and many of them are hardware-based, and so on. So, it’s a lot easier now. But back then it wasn’t.
Preston Pysh (00:08:01): And you can see how ingrained this is in the culture. If you’re on Twitter, and you’re talking to anybody that’s been in the space for a while. I mean, they’re just like you got to secure your own keys no matter what because Mt. Gox and whatnot. But you started doing contributions to the code come 2013, 2014. Talk us through what that process is like.
Jimmy Song (00:08:23): Yeah, so I’m attributed to lots of different Bitcoin projects. And there’s not just one, there’s lots. Bitcoin Core is the one that everyone knows because that’s the node software that you run if you want to validate the entire Bitcoin ledger and so on, which is very helpful because then you don’t have to compromise your privacy whenever you want to know your own transactions and so. I first started contributing to sort of like a fringe project. At the time, it was called color coins in 2013. And it was headed up by a guy in the Ukraine. And basically, the way open source contribution works is that you write code, and then you put in what’s called a pull request, which is sort of like code changes that you’d like to see usually adding some functionality or testing or something like that.
Jimmy Song (00:09:12): Somebody reviews it, and it could be one or more people, and then they accept the pull request that gets merged into the code base, and it becomes part of that software. This is just a normal process in a lot of software development organizations. So, to be honest, in industry, that level of verification actually isn’t followed a lot. I’ve been at development shops where people patch things directly on production and things like that, which is kind of crazy to me, but that’s what they do and they haven’t been burned yet. So I guess it’s okay or whatever.
That’s how open source contribution is. You make a contribution. You do a pull request. The contributor puts it in and then the people that sort of like… other people review it and then it gets merged, and so on. And this is how Bitcoin Core works except the process is a little more strict because we’re talking about people’s money, and you want to be absolutely certain that it’s not going to harm anyone. Kind of like the Hippocratic Oath, first do no harm.
Preston Pysh (00:10:14): So Jimmy, who determines that it’s a stricter process because it’s decentralized?
Jimmy Song (00:10:19): Bitcoin Core, basically is a project on GitHub right now, though, I think Wladimir has put it on various Tor services in case they have a big platform, Bitcoin Core. But basically, it’s software, and there’s a lot of core developers. I think over 500 people have contributed to core, including anonymous developers. After you put in a pull request, members of the community review it. And usually, you need multiple members of the community to say this looks good, and it’s not going to do any harm. And if it’s a critical part of the code that might cause some harm then a lot more review is required. And usually, they ask for us to prove that it’s not going to do any harm. Maybe even like some performance metrics or studies and so on just to make absolutely certain.
Jimmy Song (00:11:12): When Peter Wuille did SegWit many years ago there were a lot… I mean, there were literally like 20 people that reviewed it, and multiple people that made sure that everything worked the way it was supposed to, and so on. That level of caution is definitely good because it makes sure that nothing bad gets in. But at the same time, it’s decentralized because anyone can fork the code at any time. I can copy the entire code base and run my own software with whatever changes I want. Now, if I make a mistake in that code, then it’s entirely my fault. That’s sort of like anyone’s right. So, Luke Dashjr, for example, he’s a core developer. He has his own fork called Bitcoin Knots. And that has some of the enhancements that he wanted to see that core developers didn’t necessarily agree belong there. So, he made his own and you can go run Bitcoin Knots if you want, he makes it available.
Jimmy Song (00:12:09): That’s part of what makes it decentralized. And Bitcoin Core isn’t the only software that runs “a
Preston Pysh (00:12:48): You had mentioned earlier that Peter Wuille with his update for SegWit, this is the 2017 timeframe. For people that don’t understand what that update was this was really to allow Bitcoin to scale. This update was massive in the 2017 timeframe. How did people… So when you make this update, and you put it out there, how do you get all the
Jimmy Song (00:13:35): One of the things about Bitcoin that’s I think, more or less unique among all of the other all coins and so on is that it’s always backwards compatible, so you don’t have to upgrade if you don’t want to. It’ll run just fine. That was true of SegWit as was every other update more or less. It didn’t require “a hard fork” which would be a backwards incompatible. So because it’s a backwards compatible, no one forces anyone to upgrade. But if you do upgrade, you get all these benefits. For example, you have one of the things that SegWit fixed was transaction malleability. You can now do SegWit transactions using an upgraded node, which don’t allow transaction malleability. And if you don’t have transaction malleability, well, now you can open lightning channels much easier. And that means that you can use it for a lightning, wallet, and so on.
Jimmy Song (00:14:27): So there are all these benefits. If you want to use them, then you have to go and get upgrade, but you can run software from 2014 if you want to. And it’ll still work on the network. But if you want these new features, it’s sort of like gives you a natural incentive to go do it.
Preston Pysh (00:14:46): Jimmy, I’m sure you don’t know the exact number off the top of your head. I’m curious how many people are still running some of the older versions? Like so when you look at the latest version that’s out what percentage of the
Jimmy Song (00:15:03): I think Jameson Lopp has satoshi.info or something like that. You can go look at what clients people are running, and you can query the network. They can lie to you, but there’s no real reason to, and you can find out what client they’re running. And it might be, most of them are running Bitcoin Core. I think something like 90%, or some version of Bitcoin Core, but others are running BTC.D or Bitcoin or some of these other clients. And you can find out exactly the split. That’s something that you can go and find out at any point. Of course, not every node is broadcasting or connectable, or what Luke Dashjr calls reachable. So it’s possible that those statistics aren’t exactly accurate, but at least you can get a good idea of who’s running previous versions.
Jimmy Song (00:15:50): But generally, what I’ve noticed is that node operators or if you’re running your own node, generally what people will do is they won’t upgrade until, I don’t know, six months after it’s release. And a lot of car buyers are the same way. They won’t buy the newest year model, if they just changed everything. They’ll buy the year after because they’ll fix all of the things that they didn’t think of or whatever. That’s a perfectly legitimate way to go, especially when you’re talking about other people’s money. Different people have different risk profiles. But that’s the beauty of it is that you don’t have to upgrade if you don’t want to, but there are benefits to upgrading so many people do.
Preston Pysh (00:16:28): So there’s a lot of talk right now about Taproot, and first just describe what this is. This is an upgrade to Bitcoin, tell us… And it’s not a hard fork, but it’s an upgrade. Talk to us about what it is and what benefits it brings to the network.
Jimmy Song (00:16:45): Yeah, so Taproot is something that Greg Maxwell, I think, proposed a couple of years ago, and it’s got a lot of things. And there’s a lot of different technologies that are clumped in with Taproot. But essentially, it allows you to sort of get a little bit more privacy. Currently, if you are a single key address, it’s pretty obvious that you’re a single key address versus a multi SIG address. What Taproot does is it combines those, so you can’t tell if it’s singlesig or multisig just by looking at the address. It allows a lot more complicated logic that is very useful. So instead of two of three, you could have to have two of three, or four of five, or seven of eight, many more different combinations. And you can essentially have infinitely many conditions to unlock a particular coin. So this can be very useful for security.
Jimmy Song (00:17:44): You can, for example, have a single key, but should you lose the phone that had the single key you could have as a backup three or four of your friends whom you give slices to or you use their keys or something like that, then they can recover your coins for you, which is absolutely magical, right? That’s a huge win from a security standpoint. There’s also something called Schnorr signatures, which let you essentially do multisig, but in a way that it’s not obvious, and doesn’t take up as much block space. Right now, if you’re doing like a two of three multisig, on the blockchain as part of the transaction that unlocks that two of three multisig, you have to have two different signatures and three different public keys that are in it. And those are fairly expensive. A signature is like 70 something bytes, and a pub key is like 33 bytes. So, if it’s a large multisig like five of seven it adds up and it gets kind of expensive.
Jimmy Song (00:18:47): What Schnorr allows you to do is to aggregate signatures and aggregate pub keys. So that means that you might have seven pub keys, you can aggregate it down to one, so it ends up being like 32 bytes or something like that. A signature instead of like five times 73 bytes because of the new formatting and stuff like that, it ends up being a single thing of 64 bytes always. So all of those things are absolutely wonderful for saving block space and getting it in cheaper and stuff. But the real thing for me is the next upgrade, which this enables, which is cross input aggregation, which eventually will incentivize coin joins by making it economically advantageous to combine transactions with other people, which I think will be really good for Bitcoin privacy.
Preston Pysh (00:19:42): So, give us an example of that.
Jimmy Song (00:19:44): So, for example, what a coin join is, is you take all your inputs of a transaction and all your outputs and combine it with lots of other people’s inputs and lots of other people’s outputs. And that sort of obscures where your coins are going. Right now that if you have like 10 inputs and 10 outputs, well, then you have 10 outputs worth of pub keys and signatures. With Schnorr, you reduce them down to one and one which will be after Taproot. But with cross input, what you can do is you can take all 10 of those input signatures and combine them down to one, all 10 of those input pub keys and combine them down to one. So now you only have one signature and one pub key for 10 inputs. And doesn’t matter if you have 10 inputs or 30 inputs, right? It’s always one signature and one pub key.
Jimmy Song (00:20:35): So, from a fee perspective, you have less data going in on a per input basis. So that means that it’s going to be cheaper. So as a result, what you end up getting is coin joins, lots of coin joins. It’s economically incentivized, so more people will do it meaning that the anonymity set gets bigger and you get more fungibility, if you will.
Preston Pysh (00:21:00): So, I’m going to jump to a question I had later on. Michael [Flackman 00:21:03], he had a question about your thoughts on transitioning to a fee based, and that we’re talking years from now. But based on that update that you just described, it seemed like the miners are going to have less incentive to capture some of the fee. Like that would be some of the offset of what you just described?
Jimmy Song (00:21:20): Well, I mean, they’re not going to capture as much of the fee because essentially you’ll be able to fit more transactions in a block. But yeah, I mean, transaction demand is continually increasing, and I think that’s just going to be the case as Bitcoin gets more popular. His question, though, is about how will this transition happen? Because right now, miners are getting the miner reward, which is 6.25 Bitcoins, and Bitcoin fees, which I think is around one Bitcoin, if I’m not mistaken. Two more havings from that I think that the fees are going to actually be greater than the reward. At that point, the fees are the majority of miner revenue, and the halving after that it’ll be over 75%, and so on.
Jimmy Song (00:22:09): So I suspect that that will continue to be the case. And that will sort of change the economics quite a bit. And where miners will be very hyper vigilant about fees and making sure that they take the best transactions that pay the most, and optimizing for that rather than finding the block which many miners do. They’ll find an empty block to just get that reward sometimes because it’s optimal for them. But that will no longer be the optimum at a certain point when fees are the majority.
Preston Pysh (00:22:43): Going back to the Taproot to just cover this just a little bit more. So how many years was this in development by the person that’s developing it or the people?
Jimmy Song (00:22:53): So it’s been in development for a few years now. It’s had a lot of different people contribute to it. I think Peter might have written the actual code at the end that’s being merged, but AJ Towns and lots of other developers. I would say easily 10 developers have worked on this. There’s been a lot of another 20 or so that have reviewed it. There was a Bitcoin Core review club where they just went over all of the different aspects of Taproot and went over the code and had basically reviewed it as a group, and so on.
So, it’s been going on for a couple of years. This past year, I think, was a lot of review. They found some things that they wanted to change. So it had to be resubmitted. I believe the code has been merged into the latest release, but it’s not activated yet. And right now, the point of contention is how do we activate it? Because the last activation system that we used in 2017 didn’t go so well. So, I think that-
Preston Pysh (00:24:03): Are you talkinG Jeff Garzik thing?
Jimmy Song (00:24:06): The activation thing, that mechanism in 2017 was something called Bit9, and essentially what Bit9 does is it waits for miners to say that they’re ready, 95% of mining hash power to say they’re ready before it actually activates. It was meant to be sort of like a courtesy to the miners. Like, “Okay, you guys need to update this. And then when you’re ready, we’ll trigger it.” They saw it sort of as like their ability to veto this change. A lot of people in the community didn’t like that. This led to a lot of words back and forth, and then Barry Silbert came up with the SegWit 2X agreement, which none of the users were invited to, and none of the developers. It was just a bunch of companies. Of course, there was a lot of strife and arguing back and forth.
Jimmy Song (00:24:58): Ultimately, the users won because they said, “All right, you know what, you guys can do whatever you want, but we’re going our own way. We’re going to have something called the user activated software, and we’re going to activate SegWit no matter what do you want to do.” And that won. That made the miners capitulate.
Preston Pysh (00:25:15): This is a really, really important part for the history of Bitcoin that people are hearing right now. Because in this situation, this all happened in the summer of 2017 that he’s talking about. What really at the end of this the so what, at least in my opinion, I want to hear your so what. My so what was miners can have this opinion, but at the end of the day, the users, the people that are running
Jimmy Song (00:26:09): Yeah. That was a significant moment in Bitcoin’s history. And for me, it proved that the corporations weren’t in charge. This is just so rare in-
Preston Pysh (00:26:24): In anything.
Jimmy Song (00:26:24): … in anything because whenever corporations and government get together they get whatever they want-
Preston Pysh (00:26:30): That’s right.
Jimmy Song (00:26:31): … anywhere. This is the one instance where all these corporations came together, and they failed, and the users won. It was just sort of like, “We could win? This is actually possible?”
Preston Pysh (00:26:43): When in history has happened? Yes.
Jimmy Song (00:26:46): It was significant because like you said, you’re a master of your own node. If you run the code, they can’t make you change it. And that’s essentially what these corporations were trying to do is say, “You have to run the code that we tell you,” and the user said, “Nah. No, thanks.” They managed to get everybody else to capitulate, and SegWit2x never happened although Bitcoin Cash did happen, and that was an interesting experiment as well because we didn’t know if a hard fork would survive and it did. And it still survives to this day although it has very little of the value. I think it is like one and a half percent of the value of Bitcoin or something like that. It taught us a lot of lessons, and it showed us essentially that Bitcoin is anti-fragile in many ways.
Preston Pysh (00:27:36): Yes, very much so. Hey, so this kind of topic is interesting because when I hear complaints or you hear the FUD on Twitter, one of the things that comes up a lot of the times is this idea of hashing power being consolidated into a specific region. And the one that is most often brought up is China. And I think that what we were just talking about is this vote of a
Jimmy Song (00:28:19): A lot of that hashing power is in China right now. And the reason is actually much more practical than you would think. Essentially, a lot of chip manufacturing is in that region. A lot of heat sinks, and parts, transistors and all that stuff, it’s all manufactured over there. So it’s not a surprise that a lot of the people that can take advantage of that are Chinese. In addition, they also have a lot of really cheap electricity. In large part because the Chinese government has subsidized the construction of these very large hydroelectric dams, and basically in the middle of nowhere. Because if you’re building a dam, you don’t want a near population center because if something happens to dam then the population center is screwed.
Jimmy Song (00:29:04): So these are often in the middle of nowhere. And as a result of that because of electricity transmission costs, what you end up having is these dams that can generate a lot of electricity, but it’s not worth transmitting them to the nearest city beyond the certain amount because it costs too much. So the uniqueness of Bitcoin mining is that the mining equipment can actually be moved, it’s portable, and you can put it wherever there is electricity. And a lot of these Chinese miners, they have access to the equipment. They were able to go to these hydroelectric dams during rainy season when electricity is especially cheap, and get a lot of that excess capacity and use it for mining and so on.
Jimmy Song (00:29:51): After a rainy season, they might go elsewhere and so on. But that’s sort of been why mining has been concentrated in China. But the latest reports that I’m seeing is that less than 50% of all hashing power is now in China. There are countries that you wouldn’t expect that have a significant amount of hashing power right now, including countries like Iran, which apparently currently has somewhere around 8% of all hashing power, which I think is more than Canada, which is kind of crazy. There are other places like Russia and Kazakhstan and Sweden and Iceland that have access to really cheap electricity that ended up going towards those as well.
Jimmy Song (00:30:30): Now, as far as sort of the decentralization aspect of this hashing power. If China went offline tomorrow. If the Chinese government said that it is illegal to mine in our country, and just completely raided all of these mining facilities and shut them down, what would happen? Well, you’d still have the other 50% of hashing power. And that means that blocks would be slower, fees would be higher, but the Bitcoin network would still chug on. And in fact, this was one of the arguments during SegWit2x was even if the miners held 80% of the hashing power, which we thought was on the high end of all the miners that would cooperate with SegWit2x, Bitcoin would still have 20% of the hashing power. So, you get 50-minute blocks, hour blocks, something like that. It would still keep chugging along. And because Bitcoin has difficulty adjusting every 2,016 blocks, after 2,016 blocks passed, then it goes back more or less towards 10 minutes.
Jimmy Song (00:31:33): Now, it’s possible that the miners collude to try to attack the network. And there was a lot of discussions around that. But that ends up not being that much of a threat just given what we’ve learned about different forks. For example, Bitcoin Cash right now has like 1.5% of the hashing rate of Bitcoin, and any large miner could easily attack Bitcoin Cash, but they don’t. In part because they don’t matter. In a sense, if you’ve already won, then you don’t really care. And the thing is, the economic
Jimmy Song (00:32:19): So even if Bitcoin at that point had 20% of the hashing rate, the other 80% would be mining at a loss. And they would either go bankrupt or have to switch. So, in a sense the miners, this is one of the things that we recognize after
Preston Pysh (00:33:04): So let’s just pull the thread on a scenario that doesn’t make any sense. But if you got a sovereign nation that really wanted to go after this thing, and let’s just say, let’s just say that in China there’s 55% of the hashing there, even though we know that these aren’t the numbers. Let’s say the sovereign nation steps in and says, “We want to attack this network. We want to take it down.” They get all their miners to come online, and they try to attack it. What is the attack? When we talk about a 51% attack, describe what it is and describe in detail what it is that they’re able to actually attack. And then talk about as we would march 15 days into the future after the attack happened, how it has to be sustained, and all those types of factors. Walk us through this attack.
Jimmy Song (00:33:52): Here’s what a 51% attack is. Every 10 minutes, you essentially get a new page in the ledger. We call this a block, right? It’s a list of transactions that’s in the ledger, that goes into the ledger, that every node in the world validates as consistent with the rest of the ledger, and so on. But sometimes, once in a while, though, you’ll get two candidates for the next page, and they might have some differences. And in that case, every node is supposed to figure out, wait until one of them has an additional page built on top of it. And whichever is longer, that’s what they keep. So at any time, if you see a longer chain than the one that you currently have, then you’re supposed to take the longer chain with more proof of work.
Jimmy Song (00:34:34): That’s at the heart of what a 51% attack is, is it rearranges the ledger in some way. So a very simple 51% attack would be you first send 100 Bitcoins to an exchange as part of of that block. Say that they don’t wait for more than one confirmation, in which case, you get credited right away. Somehow you’re able to withdraw I guess 100 Bitcoins is like times 35,000, I guess three and a half million dollars or something like that.
Preston Pysh (00:35:12): Yes.
Jimmy Song (00:35:13): You’re able to withdraw three and a half million dollars, and then using the hash power you have on hand you create two blocks before the rest of the network finds one. And instead of the 100 Bitcoins going to the exchange, you send 100 Bitcoins back to yourself, in which case that transaction is no longer valid, and you have 100 Bitcoins, and three and a half million dollars. That would be a way to attack it.
Preston Pysh (00:35:42): But you’re only talking about one transaction in that block.
Jimmy Song (00:35:46): Correct.
Preston Pysh (00:35:46): You’re not talking about rearranging all the transactions in that block, correct?
Jimmy Song (00:35:50): That’s correct. So essentially, what a 51% attack is, is it allows you to do what’s called a double spend. It lets you spend 100 Bitcoins twice, once to the exchange, and once to yourself. So you get to have your cake and eat it too, essentially. You can eat it by converting it to three and a half million dollars. Now, there’s a lot of risks in that scenario. First of all the exchange might sue you. If you tried to do that, well, they know where they sent the money through the Fiat system. So, they’re going to go and find out from the bank and see if they can recover the bank that way, or slap a lawsuit on the bank, and I know of no exchange that gives you a suitcase
Jimmy Song (00:36:38): And second, you don’t know that you’re able to get more blocks than the other part. It’s all probabilistic. You don’t actually know that you have 55% of the network. Now you might, but it’s not probabilistic. The other chain might find it faster than you just because let’s say 60/40. Well, 40% of the time, they’re actually going to find the block before you so you don’t know. And essentially, you have to be longer before you can broadcast that. So, there’s a lot of tricky things there.
Preston Pysh (00:37:14): Well, don’t you have to keep up? You have to keep becoming the longer chain and outpacing everybody else block after block. How far out under an attack like this would you have to keep finding the very next block faster than everybody else for everyone else to start building on the chain that you had built?
Jimmy Song (00:37:35): Yeah. The way that nodes work is basically if I’m a node and I see one chain with one block, and another chain with two blocks then I have to take the two. That’s how the logic in the code works. But here’s a weird social aspect of it. Say you have three blocks and then suddenly something with four blocks comes along. You’re supposed to take the four, but pretty much everyone is going to be alerted that you had a three-block reorg, which is going to ring alarm bells everywhere, including exchanges, where they’re going to be like, “Okay, we accepted this deposit. Now we’re going to have to do something.” And every exchange has, or at least any good exchange should have some protocol for what they do if you have a four block reorg or something like that, especially if you take three confirmations because it might be an attack against you.
Jimmy Song (00:38:26): That means that at that point, we don’t really know what’s going to happen. It really hasn’t happened. But one of the things that you can do as a node operator, remember you’re a master of your own node. If you’re a node operator, and you’re running your own
Preston Pysh (00:39:22): Yeah. I mean, it’s crazy talk. I’m curious for a lot of these exchanges, how many blocks do they need to call it officially cleared, and they’ll let you start transacting with it again?
Jimmy Song (00:39:37): For Bitcoin, it’s usually three. Maybe if they’re a particularly strict exchange, they might require five or six. But I mean, even three blocks is a lot of hashing power. And that’s a lot of energy that you have to expend in order to do that. And then for this “sovereign nation state” that’s three blocks of mining reward at least. So that’s what 6.25 times three, 18.75. I mean, you’re looking at close to a million dollars. I mean, not quite, but I think it’s like $700,000 or something that. That’s a lot of money just to do that.
Preston Pysh (00:40:17): And you’re only reversing one transaction.
Jimmy Song (00:40:19): Yeah, I mean, I guess you could do multiple exchanges at the same time or something, if you’re particularly committed to it, but that’s $700,000 just in energy costs. There are also capital costs of all the mining equipment. And there’s, of course, sort of like social coordination to make sure that you have some arguments so people don’t just disconnect your chain. I mean, there are just so many aspects to it that an attack like that is at least in my mind not realistic.
Preston Pysh (00:40:51): Really improbable. Yeah, really improbable.
Jimmy Song (00:40:53): Socially, I don’t think anyone would accept it, and they would clearly see this as an attack and just cut it off. You could try. I mean, you could have a nation state do 100 block reorg. There’s no way in hell anyone is going to accept that because they’re going to say, “Okay, these 100 blocks appeared out of nowhere, I’m just going to disconnect it.” That’s it. Now, with other chains, this is a little different. The
Preston Pysh (00:41:27): Wow.
Jimmy Song (00:41:28): Because there’s a lot of ways in which the exchange can get screwed. So that’s just sort of the
Preston Pysh (00:41:37): So, Jimmy, Stock-to-Flow is suggesting we’re going from probably 10X from here. If true, the 700,000 becomes seven million for three blocks just within a year from now.
Jimmy Song (00:41:49): Just in energy costs, yeah.
Preston Pysh (00:41:50): Just in energy cost alone not even getting into what you were describing earlier, which is that people just unplug. When does this question that I just asked you go away?
Jimmy Song (00:42:00): I mean, I think it’ll always sort of exist in the popular mind in a way. But the longer it doesn’t happen the more people are able to dismiss it. It’s one of those things that will always be kind of a question in their mind. I mean, I hear questions about like quantum computing. It’s like one of my pet peeves.
Preston Pysh (00:42:22): Well, let’s go there. Let’s go there. I want to hear.
Jimmy Song (00:42:25): Well, the thing is very few people actually know the details of quantum computing. And they have these popular misconceptions that somehow quantum computing can do exponential calculations in linear time or something like that. That’s not the case at all. And if you know anything about quantum computing, you recognize that the engineering challenges are so difficult that you need three or four breakthroughs that are the equivalent of essentially doing cold fusion before you’re anywhere near being able to do something like that. And we still don’t have cold fusion. So, there you go.
Preston Pysh (00:43:00): Do you really see the engineering challenges as being equivalent or at parody with cold fusion type things?
Jimmy Song (00:43:07): Even setting up a Qubit is incredibly difficult. It’s literally atoms at nano degrees above absolute zero, and you have to keep them in this weird quantum state for a significant amount of time. And you have to error correct for the fact that these atoms have half-lives and things like that. [crosstalk 00:43:26]. And then you have to keep it in some sort of like that quantum state until you observe the thing that you want to observe. So if anything leaks and that shows prematurely then you’re not going to be able to observe the thing that you need to observe. There are so many little things like that from an engineering standpoint that, I mean, obviously, it’s captured the imagination of DC. So, of course, they’re going to write articles about it or whatever.
Jimmy Song (00:43:54): But from an engineering standpoint, it is extremely difficult, and I don’t think people really appreciate how difficult it is. And when I hear people talk about it as if it’s inevitable, it’s like it is anything but. Kind of like cold fusion, right? People thought it was inevitable in the ’80s because there were all these popular articles about it. I still remember Back to the Future II. It’s like there’s little Mr. Fusion. It’s like cold, it’s just going to happen. Talk to any physicist and they’re like, “There’s no way. It’s not going to happen in my lifetime.” That’s how it is.
Preston Pysh (00:44:29): I think what you get though is you have people that read a couple articles. They see Google is now they’ve got their own quantum computing, right? This is where everyone goes. And they say, “Well, if Google’s got this computer, and it’s got this many Qubits of processing, it is real, Jimmy. This is happening. No, it’s only a couple years out. So what do you say to that person?
Jimmy Song (00:44:52): Then go tell me what the Google paper actually said because what they did was actually not that impressive. Essentially, they define quantum supremacy as the ability to come up with a random number. Oh, gee, a quantum computer. Anything quantum related always spits out random stuff. So, of course, it’s going to be better at it than a conventional computer which is deterministic. Acting like that’s some incredible breakthrough is just really disingenuous, and more marketing than anything.
Preston Pysh (00:45:21): Yeah, it’s marketing.
Jimmy Song (00:45:23): And this is something about any sort of like… I just want to go on a rant here for just a little bit. This is one of my pet peeves about all these corporate R&D departments is that almost all always you have somebody in charge of that R&D department that needs to justify why that lab exists, and why their job is important. So they love press releases, and they will deceive the hell out of any reporter and make their achievements sound like it’s way more than it is. It’s not just Google. It’s every company that’s ever done anything blockchain-related. It’s like, “Oh, we did this, this and this. And it’s so incredible. And it’s going to change everything.” Yeah, they’re just justifying their jobs.
Preston Pysh (00:46:06): Well, then you combine it with the fact that the people on the other end that are reading it, they are very excited to bring up in casual conversation that they’re talking about quantum computing.
Jimmy Song (00:46:19): It’s kind of like, yeah, it ends up being something that they can use to sound smart. And the unfortunate reality is that… I don’t know, quantum computing to me has jumped the shark maybe 10 years ago. It was something that was exciting. We didn’t know that much about it. But then you learn more about the engineering challenges related to that, and you go, “Okay, there’s no way this is going to happen anytime soon.” And even if it did, there are mitigations anyway, so people place just way too much importance on stuff that the press tells you about.
I mean, we’re all over consuming media. So there’s a tendency to get manipulated by the media in ways that we don’t really recognize, and this is one of them is from a science perspective there’s the illusion of making more progress than there actually is. There’s actually very little progress and a lot of areas. It’s just a lot of people that need to justify their salary, so they make it sound like they are.
Preston Pysh (00:47:25): I want to capture some of your thoughts on some of the other things that are happening in the space mostly because I get a lot of complaints in my feed. I’m sure you get a lot of complaints in your feed. People saying, “Preston, I’m making just… I’m making more money in Ethereum, and this and that, and you’re totally missing the boat.” My background, my undergrad was in engineering. And so, that’s immediately where I gravitate way before the finance to be quite honest with you. I’m curious how you view Ethereum, and then I would also like to get into a little bit of Uniswap, some of the stuff that’s happening there. But let’s talk Ethereum first, and just from a very high level standpoint what are your concerns, and what are some of the things that just kind of raise the flag for you?
Jimmy Song (00:48:13): Short story before we get

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





With award-winning ABC reality TV series Shark Tank set for an imminent call on Kentucky, the state may soon be as well known for fast-paced unicorns (i.e. rapidly growing billion-dollar startups) as …
With award-winning ABC reality TV series Shark Tank set for an imminent call on Kentucky, the state may soon be as well known for fast-paced unicorns (i.e. rapidly growing billion-dollar startups) as it is for speedy horses.Kentucky’s pedigree for equines is well known. The city of Lexington has been called the ‘Horse Capital of the World’, while Louisville, Kentucky, is, of course, home to the celebrated annual Kentucky Derby. The Shark Tank open call will be part of Run for the Unicorns, a nexus of networking gatherings, discussions, presentations and social events that is scheduled to take place from Monday, April 29, to Saturday, May 4, 2019. The event aims to demonstrate Kentucky’s virtues as an incubator for startups.Run for the Unicorns, held to coincide with the Kentucky Derby Festival, which culminates on Saturday, May 4, with the famous

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





As a gamer, I have never been one for
As a gamer, I have never been one for

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





Forum je osmišljen, isključivo, sa ciljem razmene Vaših iskustava sa mesta o kojima smo pisale, kao i postavljanja pitanja na koje bi Vam mogle odgovoriti nas dve ili ostali članovi foruma. …
Forum je osmišljen, isključivo, sa ciljem razmene Vaših iskustava sa mesta o kojima smo pisale, kao i postavljanja pitanja na koje bi Vam mogle odgovoriti nas dve ili ostali članovi foruma. 🙂
The first poker site to offer Texas Holdem with Bitcoin was Betco. Seals with Clubs first launched in 2011 and was the first site to really create a following of players. Today Seals with Clubs has become SWC Poker, best coin casino kornwestheim. Today Seals with Clubs has become SWC Poker. Best bitcoin slot machines to play in new orleans, best bitcoin casino

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





About Me Buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card Buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card Large range of live betting events too, buy bitcoin with gamestop …
About Me Buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card Buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card Large range of live betting events too, buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card. Buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card Com offers gift cards for over 200 retailers including target, amazon, best buy, gamestop, and many more. They allow payment with bitcoin, and are even currently offering a 3% discount for customers who use the new form of payment. Buy bitcoin using amazon gift card in 5 minutes at coincola let’s say you received a generous $500 amazon gift card, but you don't need to shop anything on amazon for the present, then why not convert the amazon gift card to bitcoin to make profit when the bitcoin's price goes up? Buy bitcoins via amazon gift card with united states dollar (usd) rate: 0. Payment: time of payment: 30 minutes. Get verified for bitcoin purchase. You need to verify your account before you can buy btc with credit or debit card. This involves the uploading of your passport, national id or other documents. Once approved and cleared, you can buy bitcoins for up to 15,000 usd with your credit/debit card. But with the gift card method, you simply bypass all these restrictions and get direct access to your coins. And all you have to lose is a few of your gift cards. You can, for example, buy bitcoin with walmart gift card. The great part is that gift cards from almost all retailers work for the exchange. Pros: suitable for beginners, great support cons: limited countries available, you don’t own your own coins if you’re into bitcoin (or any other cryptocurrency) just for price speculation then the easiest and cheapest option to buy bitcoins would be through etoro. Etoro supplies a variety of crypto services such as a cryptocurrency mobile wallet, an exchange and cfd services. Go to “buy bitcoin” and look for the gift card of your choice. Open a trade with the vendor and complete the terms. Receive bitcoins directly into your paxful wallet; that’s it! you have successfully purchased bitcoin using a gift card as the payment method. The gift card era. Sell bitcoins for gamestop gift card at paxful: it’s easy, safe, and available 24/7. Choose the best offer and start trading now! Buy bitcoins with cash locally or via cash deposit. Convert paypal to bitcoin online. The above was just a brief overview of where you can buy bitcoin. Now, let's get into the details. In order to buy bitcoins, you’ll need to exchange your local currency, like dollars or euros, for bitcoin. Use bitcoin bitit gift card to redeem your bitcoins as it is the perfect tool to buy, offer and receive bitcoin. It is easy to understand the 3-step process to gift/redeem bitcoin: buy from one of bitit partners and get your gift card delivered by post or email. Redeem your gift card on bitit. Io for the leading cryptocurrencies. Coinsutra » bitcoin » this is how you can use itunes gift cards to buy bitcoins it is 2020 and bitcoin is eleven years old now. Back in 2010-11, it wasn’t as easy to buy bitcoins, but today, you have a plethora of options for purchasing bitcoins. Open to recipients who purchase a google play gift card at gamestop between april 1, 2020 and june 30, 2020. Redeem by july 30, 2020. Offer tiers: (1) gift cards $10 - $24. 99: getting started; (2) gift cards $25 - $49. 99: lock - n - loadout and (3) gift cards $50 and up: operator pack Repeated letters in the same chunk are usually separated by an X, buy bitcoin with gamestop gift card. Last week winners: Astronomical - 393.3 ltc Mystic Monkeys - 622.8 eth King of the Jungle - 361.4 eth Casanova - 673.1 eth Flying Ace - 490.1 btc Star Fortune - 596.9 eth A Night Out - 621.6 bch Miss Red - 658.5 usdt Best New York Food - 19.6 eth Jack and the Beanstalk - 110 bch Reef run - 281.2 bch Cosmopolitan - 364.8 bch Highway Stars - 126 usdt Blast! Boom! Bang! - 484 eth Lucky Bomber - 39.5 dog Payment methods - BTC ETH LTC DOG USDT, Visa, MasterCard, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Bank transfer.We have unrivaled customer support and treat players to impeccable service. Every player at 24vip online casino is a vip casino player. Play 100’s of the latest innovative slot

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.





From the Front Page Categories: The Tatiana Show TTS 255 NH State Senate Candidate Carla Gericke & GIVE Nation Co-founder Alyze Sam Published on April 28th, 2020 by TatianaMoroz Click to download …
From the Front Page Categories: The Tatiana Show TTS 255 NH State Senate Candidate Carla Gericke & GIVE Nation Co-founder Alyze Sam Published on April 28th, 2020 by TatianaMoroz Click to download audio version Liberty activist and NH state senate candidate Carla Gericke joins Tatiana and Josh in the first part of the show to discuss coronavirus response in New Hampshire and nationwide, and why she believes the

BIO:
Get Trending CRYPTOnews
- You won't miss any CRYPTOcurrency news! Sign up and Get fresh Bitcoin briefings, Blockchain news and crypto market reports delivered right to your inbox.*By signing up to our Trending News you agree to receive letters from Inechain that may sometimes include advertising or sponsored content.
1

2

Pricing Data
CRYPTOtrend Searches
Related Searches
- street racing syndicate pc
- street racing syndicate games
- game street racing syndicate pc
- street racing syndicate full pc game
- street racing syndicate windaus pc
- street racing syndicate 2
- street racing syndicate 2 pc
- street racing syndicate p
- street racing syndicate tfileru
- street racing syndicate~3
- street racing syndicate srs
- street racing syndicate portalesooru
ⓘ Find out the latest updates in Cryptocurrency News Feed with our algorithm that collects the most important news for you.
We are a team of security, new technologies and progress fans!
inEchain site is the best crypto news aggregator. We check lots of various resources to show you the whole thing. Our goal is to save your time while you are surfing the information ocean. Catch the right wave with us!
Get Trending News Daily
© inechain.com 2018-2021